I believe our society is better for it than worse. And I think big tech censorship will take us in a negative direction if we allow it to continue.
Lefty McCommunism goes on JRE and says to 200 million people “Texas has a 97% case rate of Ebola and all goods exported from Texas are poison”. Joe doesn’t object. 30% of the people believe him. 60 million customers abandon Texas and thousands of small businesses close.
Is society better off because joe rogan allowed this deplorable person to enter the marketplace of ideas? Or would it have been better if he had challenged the guest to back up the claim, or simply not had the guest on in the first place?
Being able to discuss ideas is good. But why do you need to be able to discuss your fabricated ideas in front of 200 million people at once?
Not arguing that you’re wrong; just suggesting that a seemingly simple thought experiment in this case is still very complicated on a societal scale. In general I’d argue that facts and truth are most central to productive and well-balanced societies, and combatting non-truth is therefore the most generally useful approach, but widespread discussion of ideas in general is also central.
I do not agree with everything I see on the Internet, but I also support individual freedom and choice. People should be allowed to be ignorant if that is what they choose, and rather than get angry I generally just feel empathy for most people.
I think it is best to use logic and reason, it is okay to listen to someone. If they say something that fundamentally conflicts with your personal beliefs then you are allowed to set personal boundaries to not listen to them. If someone is following you around trying to intimidate you and threatening you then you can get a restraining order. If you go out seeking people that oppose your views then demand no one interact with them anymore because they have different opinions, then many times it is you that has the problem and not them.
This framing of "we need to figure out who's wrong/who's weird/who has the problem" is really unhelpful. We should focus on the actual, practical, consequences of our choices and how that changes the world, not obsess over being normal. The practical effects of speaking freely and without challenge on a platform with 200M listeners are disastrous. It doesn't matter if it's weird for me to think that, its still true.
Walter Cronkite had a conversation with Fidel Castro and it was broadcast to millions around America. Was that an abomination, spoiling the minds of the impressionable people too weak to think for themselves?
And there was backlash: https://www.cnn.com/2020/01/24/politics/bernie-sanders-joe-r...
In both examples, politicians and news anchors are in the attention business. Same thing with conspiracy theorists. They want your attention.
Doctors aren’t supposed to be motivated by attention but by helping people improve or maintain their health.