Americans are not against it, philosophically. It is a simple consequence of economics of scale allowing big stores such as Costco and Target and Home Depot and Kroger to be able to offer better pricing and selection.
If you allow for everyone to own a large personal vehicle, via parking minimums and sufficient road capacity, then everyone has large personal vehicles because they have very high utility. And once you have the vehicle, the marginal cost to use it is near zero, so there is a lot of incentive to drive to a big box store and save money rather than shop at a smaller store downstairs.
Those stores arose because smaller more convenient commercial space is banned. And once going to the store means a drive, hunting for a parking spot, and walking, you start to minimize your trips to the store, and buy a lot more at once to minimize the basic hassle of doing it by car.
And once each trip becomes more infrequent and larger scale, then the bigger stores start to make sense, because you are never going to be walking by their store front and quickly grab something, they try to get every last dollar from you on your trip by providing a huge array of products, requiring more space.
These sorts of code and zoning are legal inventions within the past century, and they tend to be seemingly minor technical changes, but they have absolutely huge negative repercussions. I'm not advocating for elimination of zoning and codes, but rather of quick change of them to promote more walkable neighborhoods rather than prohibition of them. Elimination of all planning departments would probably be better than having them, but the best outcomes would be from radical reform of planning to be more centered on the needs of all parts of communities, rather than the most conservative of neighbors.
This in turn means only large developers can afford to redevelop. And it’s only worth their time if they can do a massive project. So instead of human scale stuff, we get massive multi-block size buildings.
Like this block in Reston VA[1]. The lots surrounding it are all a slated for similar buildings - the existing mid-rise are mostly mid-80s through mid-90s builds.
The new building is bad because it’s unnavigable. As you approach, it’s just a giant blob. There’s a CVS pharmacy in there, but try to find it - it’s not easy. Parking is a mess. And heaven help if you need to walk to the building. Oh, no bike racks either, aside from a subscription bike room for subway users (nothing on the main retail levels).
1- https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a2/Re...
And I'm not against redevelopment. I'm glad my area is turning these massive open parking lots into mixed-use buildings. I just wish they were building them in a more organic urban style. I live within walking distance of several of these projects, but rarely walk to them because I have to cross too many 6-8 lane intersections and massive swaths of asphalt parking lot (with distracted office workers hurrying to-fro).
At least for modern buildings.
The details of the multifamily structure don't seem to matter very much. If it's got shared walls and no yard, it's antithetical to the American Dream. Neighbors will perceive it as "for" either a higher or lower class, never for them.