We’re not talking about going back to the old Windows security model where you were always one wrong click away from damaging other apps or the OS, or having your data stolen.
No, it affects everyone, even the people who don’t want it.
Consider the time when Facebook got caught spying on minors by abusing their iOS enterprise certificate, and expand that to everybody.
If Apple allowed sideloading, Facebook could just remove their application from Apple’s App Store. They would still have roughly the same amount of users, because even if a person doesn’t want to sideload, most of them will do it anyway if it’s the only way to get Facebook. And now all of those people, who didn’t want to sideload, will be subject to whatever Facebook wants to do that Apple’s rules stopped them from doing.
This isn’t really about individual choice, it’s about the effect on the ecosystem. As soon as you give giants like Facebook a way to opt-out from Apple’s rules, it affects the whole ecosystem, not just the people who choose to sideload.
Sideloading would probably be quite convenient for me personally. But I would rather not have sideloading because of its effect on the ecosystem.
Although, I am of the opinion letting people just load their own personal signing keys. Its not like facebook can sign their app with their own key and expect to work on other peoples devices in that situation. Unless its signed by apple’s private key that all devices would have stored. However, if you had your own signing key you could sign the linux kernel ect or whatever you want, but its definitely not a click/tap and install situation with your own signing key.
Further, its not just doom and gloom on other systems where being able to install software from any source as you please is the default.
You’re missing the original point I was making though.
In this scenario, Facebook removes their application from Apple’s App Store and almost everybody sideloads it. Ultimately, what happens to the people who do that is their own responsibility. Yeah, I get that.
Where does this leave the people who want to use Facebook under Apple’s rules but refuse to sideload it? They have had something taken away from them. Sideloading affects them even if they choose not to sideload. It affects the entire ecosystem, not just the people who sideload. “Just don’t sideload” advice doesn’t work.
You can use Safari
If Facebook pulled their app from the Apple App Store right now, would you be forced to use Android? You'd say they can't, because they'd lose the entire iOS marketshare, which is exactly the problem: Apple are forcing people to use their Apple App Store using their iOS monopoly power marketshare. Which is anti-competitive.