At this point that's kind of what COVID feels like - nothing we tried really worked except one thing: vaccinations mean you don't get sick/die. Everything else is super muddy.
What about contact tracing? We're figuring out that masks, lockdowns, hygiene, etc. don't have that much of an effect. But where do people get COVID, shouldn't we have pretty good data on that now? It seems like a few superspreader events have a lot to do with it but that's the only anecdote that stuck with me.