I'm saying we are taught the results are correct, when, due to the impossibility of reproduction we can't know whether the results are correct or incorrect.
What should be discussed in the Milgram experiment is "we can't know the results of the experiment because one of the subjects killed themselves due to their participation. Try to consider the ethical implications, don't design experiments that might lead to psychological trauma, etc." The idea that the results being true is why we shouldn't do the experiment is wrong to do, is nonsense, because we can't know whether the results are true because can't replicate the experiment.
Yet, it's results are published as a pop-science book: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Obedience_to_Authority:_An_Exp...
Instead, these two studies if their findings, not the ethics, are discussed at all, are a perfect illustration of the problems that Karl Popper discusses regarding falsifiability.
We also should not do it again.
We can know all kinds of things with a reasonable degree of certainty even if we can't or won't verify them experimentally.
Is it obvious that humans will generally shock people until they are told not to? Is it obvious that randomly assigned students will take on the roles that they are given?
I don't think it's obvious. I think that is why the studies were done in the first place, and I am generally quite skeptical of the results. There is no way to verify them, thus teaching them is genuinely bad science.
It's certainly not obvious, so verification is informative, and that likely was the motivation for doing the experiments. However, despite their flaws - they were limited and biased in various ways - it certainly would be far, far worse science to base our teaching solely on one's assumptions/scepticism/opinion about how things should be, instead of taking into account whatever limited data these experiments provided. Sure, it would be better to have more and better data, but since we won't get it, this does provide relevant information.
Isn't it trivial to drop something out of an airplane along with the same thing but with a parachute and measure the impact velocity?
We don't have enough data on people jumping out of planes without parachutes to conclude that the parachutes are actually working. They could just be superstition.
That this remains true is due to a) no one being allowed to repeat Milgram's experiment exactly and b) more general scientific funding bodies not allocating money for pure replications.
Makes a lot of sense.
EDIT: Hell, pretend play is for weaklings, I'll be your confederate jumbo-dumbo test taker faker, and let's go a step beyond the original experiment, let's have me actually suffer serious shocks in our Milgram Repro, for your n >= 30 guineau pigs to see. Then we'll know even better and that can be the new standard. And I'll be your confederate convict prime, set aside in especially horrible solitary confinement conditions for the Stanford Prison Repro. And when you watch me and others actually suffer horribly for days on end due to your decisions, I'm sure you'll simply have zero suicidal ideation, and you'll repeat your "we can't know!!!11!!1" drivel.
https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/01/rethinkin...
https://www.vox.com/2018/6/13/17449118/stanford-prison-exper...
Why? The experiments would still be unethical, even if they led to the opposite result.
If the opposite result is "some people are prisoners, some are guards, and they all sit around and have a jolly old time" then what's unethical about running that experiment?
But why? The standord experiment was performative, it wasn't even an actual experiment, as shown from the experiment notes. How did you come to believe that it is mandatory to believe that study is valid?
This would only be true if the hypothesis being tested in these experiments was "psychology as a field needs a code of ethics". That wasn't either hypothesis.
"We need a code of ethics" does not imply "Milgram and Stanford prison proved ___ about authority figures".