Hacker News Reader

Comment by shaky-carrousel | Hacker News Reader

Well, my user experience is my problem. Other people dictating how should I experience my devices is hugely condescending.

View on HN

It becomes everyones user experience when every big company only offers their software on their own app store so they don't have to pay anyone else a cut.

Yes, but is that inevitable? Facebook tried to take advantage of Android's open nature in the past and failed outright, and that wasn't even an app store but an app launcher (Facebook Home). The Amazon Appstore is mostly used for their Fire Tablets anyway. Ditto Samsung Galaxy Store is specifically for their own devices. Epic's attempts at building their own mobile app store hasn't gotten anywhere. So what other phantom third party app store are we so afraid of? Steam?

So why are we doing this then?

Here's a small but more poignant reason: F-Droid exists on Android, not as a huge app store, but a nice FOSS-only community with its own standards of app quality and screening for malware. Surely as hackers we can at least appreciate an analogous community being made feasible on iOS, and not in a slightly more shady unofficial capacity like the jailbroken-only Cydia.

And surely, as hackers, we can appreciate having the freedom to not be unilaterally subject to the whims of a single corporation's dictates.

Who is “you” here? A end user or app developer?

That distinction is way outdated because a developer is not inherently more savvy than an end user. You could have a web developer who has no idea about how a smartphone works internally.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com