I think I get it now. The point of the experiment is to ELI5 the concept of variance to management types who skipped statistics classes :) Could be useful for some bosses I had :)
Meanwhile another worker—previously scoring 5, and getting a merit-based raise from it—did poorly with 12. The remark: "That raise went to his head. He's getting lazy".
So yeah, the value of this is in the actual doing of it.
If you are curious (and have the stomach for some MBA-ness), this article (four parts) should be well worth your time: https://archive.is/tXJhw