2. Many humans aren't smart enough to critically think about all topics. This wasn't a problem in pre-internet era since the radius of influence was quite limited.
3. So, it makes sense for some kind of checks and balances to exist unless ofcourse we want the society to crumble under the idea of pure free speech.
4. As a member of the society, I would want experts to exist who are competent and want to help the people. Similarly I would want people to listen to the experts on their matters of expertise rather than a celebrity who has no incentive to help people.
5. Usually this isn't a problem in a society where people aren't antagonistic but US in this case has a very bad recent history.
Note that most countries in the world support sensible speech (i.e. free speech minus hate+mass disinformation speech).
PS: This is most likely the minority view on HN but hey not all of us are US citizens bred through 100s of years of 2-sided fights.