Same with this. You can't allow minor anti-encryption victories here and there chipping away at privacy/mathematical rights or your great grandkids won't have those freedoms.
Nuance allows compromise, and compromise allows incrementalism. It's a classic fascist play. It's also a classic politician play to get people lost in the details so that no one truly understands their intent, i.e. "never let a good crisis go to waste".
I'm willing to be proven wrong, however.
Correct. So-called "pragmatism" and constant compromise is how we got into a ton of the messes we are in right now.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Export_of_cryptography_from_th...
Would anyone here switch party votes to a candidate who sided their way on tech privacy — even if they disagreed on other core principles like abortion, gun rights, religion in schools, etc?
Maybe a few, but I'm not convinced many.
This might show that the right arguments and lobbying can turn what is not a big political debate into a wedge over time.
Firearms and abortion became The Issue for so many single-issue voters because of well-funded, relentless fear-mongering.
You can do the same thing with tech privacy, but you're going to have to "play dirty" to accomplish the same thing, and it's going to take decades.
It's also important to note that abortion successfully tied itself into religion, which is not something you're going to be able to do with cryptography.