One of the things about 90s consumption was that the formats were generally not easy to save and carry. You could program a VCR to record a show pretty easily but radio shows would require specialized equipment if you were not there to hit "record". Tivo didn't come out until 1999, so for the most part you were either religious about recording a show or you planned to catch it at the time it was on.
One advantage to the pre-storage era was that most people had the same experience from the day before, so when you ran into them you could talk about the episode that just ran. Now it feels like we have a more isolated experience and very different schedules.