I suppose for people like Thiel it is a good question because he's an entrepreneur/VC. Looking for opinions that no one holds but may present an investment opportunity is what he's looking for.
"Which phone brand are you using?" Why is this one of the worst questions? It doesn't provide information that seems significant to most jobs, but I wouldn't characterize as even in the same ballpark as "Which President did you vote for?" that I agree would be one of the worst.