Before it was called "Scheme," Sussman was writing papers about a lisp subset that could be optimized. Some folks tried to write an optimizing compiler, known as "T."
http://mumble.net/~jar/tproject/
Common Lisp was a superset of a bunch of vendor Lisp systems, even more monstrously complex than any individual vendor Lisp.
So if I follow the author: If a CL implementation was indeed faster and better-optimized than the simpler Scheme dialect, then what was the purpose of Scheme?
The Lambda Papers [2] describe the early implementation details of Scheme, and it was these papers that influenced the development of T [3].
[1] "The History of Scheme" http://labs.oracle.com/projects/plrg/JAOO-SchemeHistory-2006... [2] "The Lambda Papers" http://library.readscheme.org/page1.html [3] "History of T" http://www.paulgraham.com/thist.html