I agree he had the solid foundation [1] [2], but it is still not that simple.
.
Most importantly at this level Buffet would have hundreds of people in his target pool of similar profiles Goldman Sacks, BCG, McKinsey and ofcourse insurance guys with similar Harvard/Stanford/Yale/MIT kind of ivy league education .
Selecting the right person would still be hard.
The pedigree of this kind of education and job helps in filtering out a ton of candidates, and keeping the pool to high quality, however it won't be a selection criteria.
[1] His academic credentials are impressive, but just to keep in mind IIT in 1972 didn't have the same reputation( guys like Jain created that their achievements) as later on especially terms of difficulty getting in - saying this as late 2000s IITb grad
[2] His younger cousin was definitely not factor in 1982 when getting hired , he wasn't Deutsche Bank CEO then