Let's not pretend that free sharing leads to starving musicians. All but a very few are already starving now, and our culture is centralized into a bland nothingness because of it.
In a free to share world, value for value wins. Artists have experimented with donation requested but otherwise free music and won.
In this model there's also no need for distribution or streaming middleman.
And no need for Fed coffers and intervention.
I don't condone piracy and I think the people infringing on an EULA should be punished if brought to a court by the infringed party.
This doesn't mean that the government should do the job for the, spy on you or even just make the job easier for them. Persecuting piracy is not convenient because the company involved is selling a lot of copies of their work, and therefore making money.
There is no reason for society to bear the cost of this exercise, if not corrupted government officials.
Maybe we can make some sense of why we cannot have a megaupload by realizing that we are talking about acting against forces that have existed for dozens of hundreds of years, namely commerce in any form. whereas the internet is barely going on 30 years, and even less as a truly mainstream medium.
> FREE IS WHEN YOU DON'T HAVE TO PAY FOR NOTHING OR DO NOTHING WE WANT TO BE FREE FREE AS THE WIND
and musicians can't have free food and housing
What’s the incentive to make movies or music just to be given away for free? Would you work for free?
Yes. I believe in the MIT licensing model.
> What’s the incentive to make movies or music just to be given away for free?
Firstly, almost all the money made from movies/music is not made by the artists who created. It goes to the shareholders of large corporations. Secondly, I believe in the hacker ethic of free information online. All media/information/etc online should be free. In the physical, making copies of anything costs time and money. Whereas copying digital items is a click of a mouse. Thirdly, artists can still make money via their fans. If fans like their stuff, those who can afford it will pay.
> Would you work for free?
Nobody is. But then again, why pay someone for something they didn't create. Licensing doesn't exist to protect artists. It exists to protect large corporations.
If people can’t afford something that means they should have a right to it anyway?
If a company can’t afford my labor at the price I set, they don’t get to take advantage of my labor.
Are we pretending that they all do?
Disney created an empire out of recycling "open source" folklore tales, then did use that influence to screw over copyright for generations to come.
This last decade it's been busy gobbling up anything worthwhile it hasn't already recycled 20 times.
Or is your time more valuable trading labor for money like most people?
I'm not the one "clamoring" for anybody to give anything away.
Disney didn't work with any of the original creators of these tales, nor their surviving relatives, yet they took that "stuff" and made it solely their own.
> Or is your time more valuable trading labor for money like most people?
I think shared culture is more valuable than having it exploited and gate-kept for purely commercial purposes.
Yet we now live in a world were institutions and people can get "punished" for singing happy birthday.
It's plainly absurd, but by now so normalized that most people stopped caring or even questioning the kind of power and influence Disney has amassed trough it's questionable practices.
If a company doesn't abide the OSS license of my software I need to sue. I want companies to sue me for eg. redistributing their content without permission. Not being fined by the government with my own money.