For any given action which is physically possible, you're likely to find someone shouting from the rooftops that it's the greatest or only way to train, and someone else reviling it as either worthless or even detrimental. Quite often both contradictory positions have huge numbers of fans.
However, the strength sports are different. Powerlifting requires training for maximum force production. Weightlifting requires training for rate of force production. Strongman requires training for strength endurance. These are three related but distinct physical qualities, and naturally, specialists in these sports train differently. To the amateur eye it can seem confusing and there's a temptation to declare that one of these is "best" and that other methods are dumb.
Otherwise, most of the fad arguments take place in bodybuilding, where the degree of physiological literacy is ... lower, on average.
... on the not-so-glorious side of the ledger, they probably know more about steroids than anyone short of an ex-East German sports scientist.
A weekend warrior may wish to optimize performance/effort, but a serious athlete must optimize performance.