As it is, browser companies[0] are the sole authority on what is and isn't a valid CA. At least the EU leadership is elected.
[0] and let's be realistic here, this means Google.
As it is, browser companies[0] are the sole authority on what is and isn't a valid CA. At least the EU leadership is elected.
[0] and let's be realistic here, this means Google.
Actually, it doesn't. There are four main browser CA root stores: Apple, Microsoft, Mozilla, and Google, and these are also the root stores of their respective operating systems (if you're on Linux, you're using Mozilla's root store, because distros do not want to run anything themselves).
Furthermore, the Microsoft, Google, and Mozilla root stores all also require inclusion in the common CA database, which is run by Mozilla. Also, Mozilla (and maybe Google) require CAs to participate in Mozilla's public lists, especially when it comes to notifying people of big CA security oopsies--all of the big CA issues have come to light on that list, and the coordination of the responses by browsers has been done by Mozilla.
So the biggest authority on who a valid CA is? Mozilla.
If against the odds somebody had built a trustworthy Russian CA and it was currently in the root trust store for Firefox (and so likely everything else) then we might have this question to ponder, although the answer is likely "No" since this hypothetical CA isn't doing anything wrong, but that's a hypothetical very different from reality.
Not an elected group, true. But a foundation with a public charitable goal, and an entity with much less interest in being able to intercept communications than states.
I think it's better of in the hands of an un-elected foundation than in the hands of an elected, but politicized entity with interests in intercepting communication.
Mozilla might well not be around forever, considering the state of their market share. And let's be honest, as long as their main source of funds comes from Google, politically speaking they end up as a fig's leaf around Google's interests. As far as we know, they might take certain decisions about the life or death of any given CA after someone at Alphabet picks up the phone. Maybe they don't do that, but there is no guarantee nor formal process to address this - particularly not in Europe, since all these are US entities.
A more direct and confrontational approach would be for browser companies to do what website owners have effectively done, which is to agree in advance to implement some sort of annoying pop-up (shown every time the browser updates) saying "Do you want the EU to weaken your security and enable spying? [Yes] [No]", like those annoying cookie pop-ups.
The difference being, of course, that the cookie pop-ups are designed to dark-pattern users into giving away their rights, and to blame the EU unfairly, whereas these browser pop-ups would be to help protect users' rights and to correctly blame the EU (assuming the regulation passes).
it isn't (directly anyway)
for the last set of elections: they even held televised political debates with candidates
then selected someone that hadn't even been mentioned (Von der Leyen)
- hadn't won any primaries
- hadn't attended any debates
- said zero words about their plans for office
- and hadn't even run for president
because that's exactly what happened with Von der Leyen's appointmentFurthermore, fixing the anti-democratic features of the EU requires giving it more power[0]. The reason why the EU has so many appointees is because it represents member states, not people. This is true for every international organization. The only way to have international organizations that are democratically accountable is to actually have a notion of international citizenship - in other words, to agree that, say, German votes are allowed to dilute Spanish ones. This is tantamount to political union.
Because the EU did not want a political union[1], they instead decided to limit the amount of elected representatives in the system, and let member states fill in the rest. So you don't get to vote for Ursula von der Leyen, you get to vote for the person who appointed the person who gets to vote for Ursula von der Leyen. Yes, this is complicated and stupid, but it's also the thing that keeps the EU international rather than sovereign. If you don't like it you should push for reforming the EU into a properly democratic single country.
Also, if you think the EU is entirely undemocratic, then let me ask you: when was the last time you voted for anything in the World Trade Organization, NATO, or the United Nations? The WTO in particular are the kings of antidemocratic policy laundering, so much so that it would make Ursula von der Leyen blush.
[0] For the record, giving it less power reverts back to the international default, where governments are entirely sovereign within their own territory and powerless without. So, say, the French have 100% say over who their leaders are and what they do, but 0% say over international affairs, because they aren't citizens of those other countries.
[1] This is almost certainly no longer the case now that Britain is out of the picture.
not alone, no, but when combined with:
- a parliament made up of directly elected representatives that can't legislate, modify or repeal previously passed acts
- the ratcheting of transfer of powers in direct opposition to what the people of Europe want (ignoring No referendums on the Constitution of Europe and passing it through regardless): the "Monnet method"
- deliberate "degenerative proportionality": a Maltese voter has 30x the representation of a German (makes no sense in the organ that's supposed to represent the people)
- the concentration of executive power via the mass transfer of power from elected national parliaments to the council
it's beyond a joke to say it's democratic> If you don't like it you should push for reforming the EU into a properly democratic single country.
I don't have a problem with the idea of a federated Europe, as long as the people voted for it
the problem the EU has is: the peoples of Europe wouldn't, so it's being done by slowly by deception instead
and by design it's impossible to revert (unless you leave entirely, which is extremely difficult)
> Also, if you think the EU is entirely undemocratic, then let me ask you: when was the last time you voted for anything in the World Trade Organization, NATO, or the United Nations?
I don't remember these organisations pretending to be democratic (let alone having legions of fans online stating that they are)
Does it matter? They're still a bigger stumbling block to democracy than the EU's various collections of appointed positions are. All of the anti-democratic features you mentioned are present in other international bodies, but amped up to 11. It is unfair to single out the EU as wholly responsible for this.
Also, I feel the need to defend the EU on one other point: ratcheting. If you have a free trade area in which member nations are allowed to pick-and-choose each little bit of the EU treaties, then you lose the benefit of the EU, and just get a bunch of top-heavy bureaucracy with no other benefit. Furthermore, the things that the EU tends to be really adamant about - such as freedom-of-movement[0] - are essential for making the bloc work at all.
The EU has such dogged fans because people don't want things like freedom-of-movement taken away from them, and nobody's made a serious proposal for fixing the EU's problems aside from "leave and go back to having borders everywhere" or "federal Europe". Alternatively, they're Americans who happen to oppose strict immigration control[1] and, thus, oppose euroskeptics purely by association.
[0] This is also why the UK's original "free trade without freedom of movement" proposal was shot down so quickly. The biggest mistake the west made was convincing the whole world to let goods move faster than people do. This constitutes a transfer of power from labor to capital.
[1] As you might have already guessed from the previous footnote I am an American who opposes strict immigration control. I'll at least entertain the thought of the EU needing reforms, though.
That’s fair. A well run society has more than democracy - it also has skilled civil servants, a commitment to rule of law, protection for individual rights, etc.
But when people complain the EU isn’t democratic enough, they mean it’s too focused on skilled administrators.
That doesn't sound like a sad state of affairs to you? It's like responding to the PATRIOT act by saying "Probably tech companies will refuse to comply and deal with the federal government in court if they make a stink about it."
While that's true to some extent, I don't find that to be the case in this specific area (ie. trust store and/or encryption). Are the browser vendors unfairly applying rules (ie. favoring incumbents)? Are their requirements too arduous? Are they not revoking bad CAs? It's not clear what this regulation is supposed to solve.
I'd rather see overreach stopped before it starts, but in the absence of that, I'd like to see it stopped by any means we have, including civil disobedience and litigation.
In this context: remove CAs that issue MITM certificates, and loudly and repeatedly say "So you're prosecuting us and demanding that we include a known-insecure CA that's used to make the Internet less secure? Is that what you'd like to say to these cameras, the entire Internet, and people who will see this played repeatedly while they decide whether to vote for you in the next election? Or would you like to drop this?"
In principle Apple, Google, and Microsoft can do whatever they want, but well, go back and see the history of such interventions for yourself and draw your own conclusions about where the crucial decision was made.
So how about we stop this proposal in its track right now instead?
Involving a government doesn't magically make things better 100% of the time, the actual tangible proposal still has to be better than what is happening in the market. Is that the case here? We don't need to have an abstract argument about whether governments or private corporations are always better; look at the specifics of this proposal and see if they're good for browser security.
We have a lot of data that suggests that EV certificates do not provide meaningful security because the "green lock" doesn't actually guarantee what consumers think it does. Independent of what you think about governments overall, is it good to have a new standard that ignores that research in favor of having yet another kind of special certificate that is displayed to users as more trustworthy?
In this specific case, Camerfirma is still considered by the EU government to be a trustworthy certificate provider even though all major browsers have blocked the company for repeated mistakes/policy violations. Independent of whether or not you trust the government overall, is a standard that would require browsers to trust Camerfirma a good idea?
I don't think we should immediately assume any government involvement in the market is a bad idea, but there's also real danger in saying, "well, in theory it might be preferable for this to be more democratic", and then never asking the followup question, "but in practice, is this specific proposal good?" Yes, you're 100% correct, it's not immediately obviously bad across the board for the government to control something. But when I go beyond what is immediately obvious to me, then I start seeing arguments from Mozilla and other security researchers that (in my mind) make a lot of sense.
The current way TLS is managed has far more democratic legitimacy. You can pick your browser and operating system i.e. root store, and then edit it if you want. EU dictating one is worse in every possible respect.
By rolling out QWAC, we would be reducing the agility of the ecosystem and preventing automated certificate issuance methods like LetsEncrypt which have improved the status quo immensely. And for what gain?
This is not a debate over whether certificate issuance should be controlled by corporations versus the government.