Hacker News Reader

Comment by cleancoder0 | Hacker News Reader

> I found it odd that you thought I was talking about foreigners.

You mentioned that this cannot be said for a lot of EU countries. Turks born in EU do not have to learn German. Immigration within EU is free from language requirement too.

I do not even understand why do you think minorities not learning Serbian is impressive? Croatia and Kosovo both have schools that can use Serbian in their curriculum and no one is forcing Croatian on them. Similar things exist for Czech and Hungarian. No one is forcing these minorities to go to schools to learn Croatian.

> Didn't those two breakaway republics declare independence?

And were immediately annexed by Russia? How independent is that? Who's the new cultural head of these independent republics?

View on HN

>You mentioned that this cannot be said for a lot of EU countries. Turks born in EU do not have to learn German. Immigration within EU is free from language requirement too.

So Turks in Germany can have schools in Turkish for their children? Do you have a source for this?

>I do not even understand why do you think minorities not learning Serbian is impressive?

Because language rights are central for the survival of minority communities.

>Croatia and Kosovo both have schools that can use Serbian in their curriculum and no one is forcing Croatian on them.

Yeah, when they are not being stoned in Kosovo or have their Cyrillic signs smashed in Croatia.

> So Turks in Germany can have schools in Turkish for their children? Do you have a source for this?

Sure: https://www.schulentwicklung.nrw.de/materialdatenbank/materi...

That's the official lesson plan for non-German lessons in NRW; other German states have similar plans (teaching is devolved to the states in Germany). Notice that this is the plan used in the state-sponsored lessons; private schools are free to use their own plans.

Umm guys, education is about children's rights and it has to be mandatory so that your parents won't be able to override your rights even if they have something against their minority language or against the language majority.

1. The right to mother tongue: wherever in the world, the child must learn the mother tongue(s) of their parents to support the cognitive and psychological development.

2. The right to participate in the society as an equal: the child must learn the official language(s) of the society well enough to be able to understand and participate in the democracy, business, art etc.

On top of that, the bulk of the school curriculum can be in a yet another language, no problem, as long as these rights are ensured as well.

And oh, I forgot about this part.

>And were immediately annexed by Russia? How independent is that? Who's the new cultural head of these independent republics?

They were not immediately annexed, no. Russia didn't even recognize them for a couple of years.

Abkhazia and South Ossetia declared independence and stayed independent.

Crimea for some reason was annexed, despite leadership in Crimea wanting the same status given to two countries mentioned above.

Donetsk and Lughansk also declared independence years ago, only now is Russia doing something other than financial/military support.

So I read a bit more about Donetsk and Luhansk and while I can see the similarities where Ukraine = Serbia and NATO = Russia, unfortunately the similarities stop soon when you realize that Kosovo (= Luhansk or Donetsk), establishes a democratic society that includes Serbian minority by default in the government, where Donetsk and Luhansk start banning Ukranian passports, banishing Ukranians, massive antisemitism movements, and basically want to become dictatorships similar to Belarus.

Similarly, Ukranian army is not targeting Russian civilians in these regions and is not banishing them to Russia. There is no displacement of millions of Russians in Ukraine.

If you are trying to say "NATO bombing of Serbia is justified", therefore "Russia war against Ukraine should be too", therefore hypocrites, it does not really work.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com