My boss recently emailed me (from a weird email) saying the landlords payment hadn't gone through and we needed to wire them the money pronto and they were stuck traveling and couldn't do it. This was a scam.
In my neighborhood folks rent out houses for great deals, the landlord is temporarily traveling and can't meet. A fair number of these turn out to be scams.
I just mention this because if some low level support agent providing support to FREE accounts was able to reset an account based on this narrative - and no phone access - that would be HUGE security HOLE.
If google starts allowing recovery of passwords by folks overseas who are "stuck overseas" with no documents - game over. We are focusing on the folks getting locked out, but google is doing a fair bit to keep folks from getting taken over.
I have a 2FA key (hardware) they ask me for once a month. I'm not sure how someone takes over my account unless they get access to my computer with remote access and then maybe re-uses a session somehow? Even then I have to re-auth when doing security steps... so it's a bit weird to have an account takeover like this.
My request. For a fee of $1,000, an in person visit, fingerprints, and research effort, communication with existing account holder for any disputes (ie, someone sold them the account) google would allow for an account recovery. This last step is what is missing. Charge $2,500 even. In some cases that would be worth it and allow them to make a pretty good job on recovery. Even wipe the account / lock all old messages so they are unreadable on recovery.