It is bad faith because Respondent was not using the trademark to pretend to be Red Hat. Tarnishing a trademark would require misleading users to think that you are representing the company. If I create a website called microsoftsucks.com and detail reasons why I think Microsoft sucks, that is fair use. If I pretend to represent Microsoft on that site, then that is tarnishing Microsoft's trademark, or if I use the domain to sells shirts then that may not be considered fair use.