Yes, the "dual register file" is probably the most intriguing to me.
This looks like a renaming scheme used in some old micro-architecture (Intel Core 2 maybe) where ROB receives transient results and acts as a physical regfile, at commit reg value are copied to a arch regfile.
But in your uarch the physical regfile is decoupled from ROB, which must correspond to your commitQ.
I wonder if this solution is viable for a very large uarch (8 way) because read ports to copy reg value from pysical regfile to arch regfile are additional read ports that can be avoided with other (more complex) renaming scheme.
These additional read ports can be expensive on a regfile that already has a bunch of ports.
Any thoughts about this?
But I haven't read much of your code yet, that's just a raw observation