If they had just called what was released yesterday an iPhone 5 there would have been much less disappointment. As far as a full redesign goes, I don't see a whole lot Apple can do. The height and width of the current phone seems near perfect. They could expand the screen a bit to be edge to edge, get rid of the physical home button, and taper the back (seems less likely now that they are using a dual antenna design) I guess.
I just don't see a much larger screen iPhone coming. I think Apple has already said if you want a large screen iPhone, buy an iPad.
I still think there were no breakout features this time round though. Siri being '4S' only is a bit of a cheek - and everything else felt firmly incremental. Even iOS 5 doesn't excite me much except for the notification system (though that is much appreciated).
Apple are experts in taking a feature their competitors technically have, but few customers use - and taking it 'mainstream' - nothing along those lines this time.
It seems to me that their next breakthrough in that regard is likely to be the NFC stuff, presumably to arrive with iPhone 5.
I now FaceTime with my Family quite regularly.
I agree though, I love my iPhone 4 and am sure the 4S with it's incremental updates will simply be more-awesome. But for better or worse, I think version number bumps are now associated with big upgrades on iPhones.
Expectations are set high, but then Apple will quite happily just ignore everyone's expectations and do what they want.
Personally, I look at the specs for a 4S and have trouble coming up with anything new that I'd want to add. But of course that doesn't mean other people can't, I may just be unimaginable.
By releasing a 4s, Apple is most likely signaling that there will be a radically new phone released soon. (less than a year) I'm going to get a 4s (the new features are great and I can't really wait 6 months) but I probably won't ever actually get the 5 due to carrier lock-in.
Example:
(1) cancellation fee after 12 months at ATT is $325 - 120 = $205. If you had bought an iphone 4 in July 2010 the cancellation fee today would be $165.
(2) new iphone costs $200
(3) a 16 month old iphone 4 in good condition sells on ebay today for between $350-$375. A few months ago that was around $400+.
This is a twist on the old Jade plan for Macbook upgrades where you sell your old Macbook every year and buy a new one, always staying under warranty and continually upgrading -- it's not flawless, you will have to shell out a few bucks here and there but it's a pretty good system.