The more accurate framing is "100% of people pay for 100% of people to have the opportunity to go to college".
A good analogue is insurance: even though 99% of people might never file a claim, it's not 99% subsidizing the 1% the do-- it's 100% paying for protection from financial ruin that 100% receive.
Your framing would apply if there somehow were a group--people with blue eyes, people born in May, whatever--to whom access was limited.