This drives me a bit nuts about security people in the age of cloudscale. They assume you don't mind MFA'ing every hour and are manually doing logins and accesses for everything. Yeah, uh, I need to script orchestration on several hundred machines at once, and orchestrate/access on the scale of hours or even days for some things like "Big Data" backups or restores.
If certificates are anything like SSL certs and the horrorshow cli tools / options / management involved in those, no thanks. I'd rather have an automated sshkey switchover, or for stateless just routinely cycle the infrastructure with new keys.
It's been a long time tenet of security that you want an open algorithm that gets broadly and publicly challenged so you know its secure. Well, in the age of the state actors, this might not be the whole truth.
I think layering some klugy not-invented-here obfuscation atop the more battletested methods is a useful and important deterrent/delay. Sure someone will figure it out, but they have to TRY HARD. A lot of the institutional attacks seem to be based on human attacks on standardized systems, which HAVE to allow human access and vectors.
So in AWS land, secrets manager is secure unless you get the permissions. Then you have everything. But if each of those secrets has some whacko obfuscation for the various apps, then that is a big slowdown to the human attack vectors.
And the state actors? Well, even they have budgets. They'll probably move on to easier targets. If a state actor is motivated at targeting your company in particular, well, given that they'll have malware in the firmware of your hard drives and motherboards and the like, you're probably helpless.
Finally, what really bothers me about most security is that it leaves one of the most important "canaries in the coal mines" aspects of security: honeypots. Sure do the diligence on securing the access, but how about some turnkey approaches for setting up honeypots to detect when people are poking around? Honeypots are perfect for that, because the devs only care about the stuff they are working on. The intruders are doing the scanning.