It came about due to https://www.debian.org/vote/2021/vote_002 leading to DDs fearing being individually targeted due to how they did or did not vote. On technical matters, I support the idea that voters' reputations be affected by their voting record. On matters like this vote (please read it!), not so much. Maybe it's OK for the voting record to be public, but any individual harassment that might follow would be out of order and is a good reason to make such votes private.
This is but 1 example; but this alone literally is called infighting. Your example proves me right. Let's not forget how debian also went after Linus. How they have gone after how many other developers?
>On matters like this vote (please read it!), not so much. Maybe it's OK for the voting record to be public, but any individual harassment that might follow would be out of order and is a good reason to make such votes private.
Oh I understand all too well what's going on.
Citation needed. I don't see anything dying for the last 15 years.
Debian's constitution says the Debian Developers may vote to publish "position statements about issues of the day", and some developers want to use those for the sort of political statement that might make people angry with them.
Maybe I used the wrong word? Another comment also disagrees.
infighting: Prolonged and often bitter dissension or rivalry among members of a group or organization. Example: Bureaucratic infighting.
>Debian's constitution says the Debian Developers may vote to publish "position statements about issues of the day", and some developers want to use those for the sort of political statement that might make people angry with them.
I would agree that they used to have a requirement for transparency and this change is an affront to the community.
The problem or reason why this is changing is the real big deal. They have a mass developer exodus. People don't feel safe having a public vote anymore. This is because they fear retribution. That is infighting.
https://itwire.com/business-it-news/open-source/debian-devel...
https://wiki.debian.org/Teams/Community?action=show&redirect...
Doesn't pretty much every western democracy have anonymous voting so people can pick what they actually want to without without fear of reprisal?
Yes, but Debian principles are transparency.
Like I completely understand and agree that the change to secret voting is counter to their project.
But I also understand why they suddenly need secrecy.
Death spiral. Well that sucks. Where next? Ubuntu is horrible, Fedora, maybe? Manjaro?
now they fear this tyranny of the private list, hence secret voting is considered a protection.
From my research the debian developers have been quitting for the Arch/Manjaro ecosystem.
HN can be considered a healthy group, but most of the people here are anonymous already. What gives?
I look a this behavior in myself and wonder why I use all these acronyms. I feel sometimes that if others are not anonymous the extreme responses when you have a new idea or say something wrong are part of the problem. Why expose myself when the people criticizing me do not? So it is kind of a race to the bottom.
I'm not anonymous here, yet the most heated discussion never spilled over to my personal mail address, but I got some genuine questions and a couple of job offers.
So, other people's anonymity choice is not something I care about. They can be who they want. I'm here as a person, with my own choices, with my own tone. My choices brought me some great discussion, sometimes kind, sometimes not. Regardless of my correctness and knowledge level on the issue, I always came out improved from every single one of them. Either on the knowledge front, or the actual ability to discourse, or both.
So, it's not a kind of a race to the bottom. Other people's choices shouldn't bother anyone, unless the other party doesn't harass or cross some well defined lines of being civil and ethic.