Hacker News Reader

Comment by anemoiac | Hacker News Reader

I don't have a particular source on hand, but I think it's pretty widely accepted that women outperform men, in terms of attending and graduating college, in the US today. That may not be true within certain STEM specialties, but I'm not sure that (potential) exception to the rule would be sufficient to overwhelm the general trend (outside of a few major tech hotspots, perhaps).

Obviously other factors, such as the availability of high-paying, non-degree-requiring jobs in male-dominated industries (ex. oilfield work) might obfuscate other trends in some cities, but I'd expect young women to increasingly earn more than young men across the country if they continue to outpace them in educational achievement.

View on HN

I generally agree - the facts are rights, but their application do not address my question. The educational achievement doesn't translate to high paying careers. So women are graduating from college at a higher rate, and getting advanced degrees at a higher rate. But what makes a difference (for pay) is what subjects those degrees are in and what jobs they get after graduation.

For example, I know a woman who has two masters degrees but doesn't really work. She is about 35 and has spent most of her life in school, focusing psychology. Even if she had focused more on working in the field of psychology than just serially earning degrees, she would still be at the lower end of pay due to those jobs paying less than STEM jobs.

This anecdotal experience seems to be backed up by the BLS study that also acknowledges that more women are graduating college but that choice of career/subject has not seen that translate into higher pay. That's why I was wondering what is driving the inverse scenario in those cities. Is it that women are choosing STEM there? Are policies in place that promote women from not working low paying jobs (ie makes it more attractive to be a homemaker instead of pay for childcare while working hospitality etc). Or is it cultural, like lower birth rates or more male caretakers?

Well college grads typically make significantly more than those without college degrees, so if there's enough of an educational attainment gap between men and women in a given city, it shouldn't really matter what anyone majored in. A bachelor's degree in anything is the difference between earning $30k/yr and $50k for many people.

That said, the prevalence (or lack thereof) of high-paying industries with gender-imbalances could also contribute to the scenario described by the article. For example, a notable lack of STEM jobs or a local economy based around healthcare could both lead to a city's young women earning more than its young men.

Yeah, that's why I was hoping the article would go into detail. But sadly it doesn't give any type of analysis for the potential underlying causes.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com