Comment by SurfScore | Hacker News Reader

Comment by SurfScore | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

We applied with SurfScore. It's designed as a universal achievement-reward system for the Internet, similar to videogame achievement systems(GamerScore, etc.) People are able to perform tasks (simple things like uploading a photo to facebook) and earn SurfScore for it, which can be redeemed for prizes. It's designed as a new form of advertising...companies can institute achievements for their own websites(it can be anything, as long as it doesn't cost money--you don't pay to watch a commercial), and people will see a tangible reward for doing whatever task they specify.

This takes advantage of the interactivity of the Internet, while also revolutionizing advertising as something much more appealing than just beating you over the head with banner ads and commercials. Advertising wants you to do something, but does it in a way that usually just pisses you off. We hope to change that. http://www.SurfScore.com

Isn't this just a fancy derivative of "fill this form out and we'll send you a free iPod?". Because that's all it is..

If you tell me people want achievements, well.. Achievements in games feel good because there's actual skill involved, and it feels like you mastered something. You can't say the same for doing random tasks online. You can't just throw a word like 'achievement' or 'score' on top of what you're doing, and think the effect will be the same.

What's wrong with getting a free iPod for filling out a form? The problem with these types of companies is execution; they're usually really shady and have a lot "catches". If a company came along that could get rid of all that and do it right, wouldn't you be filling out forms too?

Nothing wrong, just that you're going to have difficulty finding advertisers that will agree to this type of advertising. You're not in any way solving the problem of finding relevant audiences for their ads. You're just throwing an incentive for random people to do things for prizes, and hope they will buy whatever the ad is about. But users just want the free goods.

The problem is not how to make users interested in an ad. The core problem is connecting an ad to a relevant audience. You can't fake interest in an ad that's not relevant to what you want at the point. People have tried that with FB ads, but the CTR are horrible, and people get pissed when they see the ad had nothing to do with the actual product.

You know, you're absolutely right. Any suggestions?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com