Huh? I have no idea what this is supposed to mean. Tile based memory refers to the GPU, and you don't have to rewrite your GPU software from scratch, that's insane? That's what Metal is for. Whatever this is supposed to mean I'm pretty sure it's not even wrong
I understand that in an abstract context, and I guess it depends on your day-to-day needs. For me, I was incredibly excited to get an M1, and that lasted about a day until I realized that it was just doing everything I was doing on my Intel Mac and lot faster. It doesn't even occur to me that I'm using an M1 because I have had zero speed bumps. The only time I've even been reminded of having an M1 was when the computer told me I needed to install Rosetta to run a program.
My M1 does everything I expect a computer to do. So much so that it's disappeared and I'm just back to "is there a Mac Native version?" for x.
I wonder if the comments were the same back when transitioning from the 68k to the PPC.
Pretty much. There were exceptions, things like early image edition programs that were slow on PPC Macs because of 68k emulation, but for most people it wasn’t an issue and anything advertised as Mac-compatible ran just fine. Again, in the worst case emulation corresponded more or less to the performance of a high-end 68040 CPU (without its maths coprocessor, which was an issue sometimes).
Well that is simply not true.
https://isapplesiliconready.com
Notably, MS Office and Adobe’s stuff is compiled for ARM.
Admittedly that's still pretty anecdotal. It's not like each one of those engineers has rigorously tested all alternatives.
But still, no complaints and people are loving the battery life and lack of heat.
The dongle situation is unchanged from 2016-onward Intel Macs and has been resolved with the latest MBP models. The dongle situation was absurd but never thaaaat bad; you just had to buy a $70 dock dongle thingy.
Single external monitor support on the lower-end models was lamentable, but also not a dealbreaker in an era of ginormous 4K displays.
Lack of M1 support in software is almost a non-issue. Rosetta emulation is so fast that nobody notices or cares. The only exception has been our Docker-based stuff; took some massaging to support the new arch.
My m1 max laptop is so good that if it broke today, I'd lament having to wait for a replacement, but wouldnt hesitate. Felt the same way about m1. And thats coming after three decades of low level programming work on dos, windows and linux x86 with the best hardware money could buy.
I gotta say it's been really wild watching "epistemic closure" in action. There are clearly two different sets of facts and two different realities based on them that have emerged at this point, one where M1 is slower than x86 and requires everything to be emulated and USB doesn't work and you can't use external displays and it's a closed and locked-down system that is NEVER going to get a linux port, and one where it's got massive IPC and great battery life/etc and everything basically Just Works and the linux people are thundering along and have a basically workable system. People are living in like totally different worlds, one where it's just more apple trash and one where it's the best thing since sliced bread and actually better than the x86 alternatives.
I dunno if it's people who just haven't used it, or people who are ideologically opposed to apple's designs, or just super hate macos, or what, but even in the benchmark space it's become completely bimodal, you've got Anandtech where it's showing up to 3.5x the IPC at 0.7x the clock of competing designs in SPEC cpu benchmarks suites, and you've got Hardware Unboxed where it barely edges out current designs at iso-power even in ARM-native builds of Cinebench.
https://www.anandtech.com/show/17024/apple-m1-max-performanc...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0bsjUMz3EM&t=726
tbh I've been thinking something similar in general - the synthetic stuff seems amazing, but it does seem like it has some problem actually putting power to the ground in real applications. Cinebench is native, so that shouldn't be a factor, and it should be something that makes great use of that absolutely wild FP32 IPC, so why isn't Apple running away with it anywhere near as much as SPEC shows it should? There's something weird there and I can't quite puzzle it out.
I'm saying they're incomplete in terms of hardware/firmware.
It's a critism of the hardware not implementing full protocols so that devices work and so that you can change and upgrade your computer. Some people don't want or need to do that, just like I'm not very good with automobile maintainance and don't care about parts availability for my car or that it has all electrical ground points in the engine compartment inaccessible behind plastic. Someone else can deal with that. And that's what Apple computers are. Bad computers that are someone elses problem.
As for usb3 speeds, I mean, oh well. I probably wouldn't notice if the ssd runs at 400 vs. 500mb/s. Minor speed differences are less noticeable than quality of life things like noise, battery life, screen quality, stuff like that. To each their own.