That's fair. Uniswap was a poor choice because people do use centralized exchanges, though I don't know of a single one that allows you to earn returns by providing liquidity. There are far more complex DeFi products that are much harder to replicate but people here wouldn't understand them.
My argument is merely a counter to his "databases are faster therefore they are better" when in reality decentralized finance is better on almost every dimension. Take Uniswap on polygon:
- Trades complete in < 2s
- Trades cost less than 1c
- There is no external party risk, you are in complete control of your funds.
- You can provide liquidity for a return - playing the part of the house.
- Any app can integrate without permission and all API uptime, permissions, latency, etc is handled by the Blockchain.
- Many hundreds of apps have already integrated with it and you can use them alongside it for a better UI, or multiple trades, or routing through many exchanges.
The advantages you get of centralization:
- a small increase in speed
- save 1c on every trade
For that you take on custody risk, they could run off with your funds or they could be hacked. You don't have the chance to earn income, you get no or few integrations, you get no choice of UI, you can't fork it if the company turns evil, and you can be banned or restricted at any time.
It's night and day difference in the experience.
I'm going to write an article on DeFi composability because it's super underrated.