I am looking at you, EU cookie notice.
I know exactly what I am ready to accept - and what I want to reject. The law says "you have to repeat your preferences individually for each and every domain, you cannot have a system that applies your preferences automatically to everyone"
As a consequence I stand my ground: The law - not the companies - is nagging me.
In fact one of the failures of DNT was its lack of regulatory backing, and its successor is specifically being designed to be a browser wide, GDPR compliant solution.
You are wrong. I have in fact read the law and if you think this you have not. Please do so if you are curious what it does in fact forbid, you can start here: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...
You can start here: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELE...
You will discover under section (17), that the lawmaker does - in fact - force everyone to give specific and informed consent. Which means that each and every website has to provide me a wall of informative text and a specific button to click. Aka: nag me.
I am not allowed to give a blanket "accept all" or "reject all" or "accept analytics, reject marketing" consent for all websites as this would be categorised as "uninformed and unspecific" consent, which is illegal. So the EU is responsible.
Edit: And besides, the point of this is analytics is unnecessary. As such, a company could opt not to have it. No consent required for an absence. They don't have to nag you for nothing.
These corporations must be raised properly and reminded that they too have to follow the law, or they will do to the whole world what they have already done to the US. Nobody outside of the US is looking for such a society, so it makes sense to take as much action as is required to prevent it.
The same thing would happen with Spotify right now, if it's not protected. Amazon, Apple and Google don't need music to make money, they don't need to be competitive in that sector to sustain their music activity, they can just use their quasi-monopoly in other sectors to kill all the other players.
What I have a problem is certain most righteous company on the planet are claiming Spotify as evil because they paid less to labels / singers etc.