Even further, in my experience this view varies quite wildly depending on where you're at in the states, both geographically and economically. I grew up in a very small, rural public school. Since it was such a small school (my graduating class was < 50) many people did it all. AP classes, played multiple sports, played in the band or sang choir, etc. There was almost no siloing into the expected social "roles" that are common place in media such as jocks or geeks. Everyone just did their own thing.
On the other hand, my partner attended a school 15 minutes away that was more than 5x the size and had a much different culture, much so more inline with stereotyping to fit the "norms".