'Tax logic' is an oxymoron and a trap for smart technologists to fall into. Tax codes are not logically consistent or clearly defined. They're a bunch of illfitting laws, beauracratic/regulatory guidance and interpretations of judicial decisions.
I tell folks working in this area to accept the illogical nature of it all and to be ready for all sorts of arbitrary last minute changes. As the article points out understanding time plays an important role here too - when do different tax treatments take effect is an important question to answer.