To steal from Frank Zappa: Legal isn't the same as allowed, allowed isn't the same as fair, fair isn't the same as just, and just isn't music.
To steal from Frank Zappa: Legal isn't the same as allowed, allowed isn't the same as fair, fair isn't the same as just, and just isn't music.
I don’t get why purchasing a stolen NFT is different than purchasing a stolen guitar from a pawn shop. Shouldn’t the previous owner be able to use the courts to demand the return of the item that was stolen from them?
Or is this just something that hasn’t been tested yet?
"Code is law" is a mantra chanted by people in no position to make it so.
Mark the result of theft or other illegal transactions, and any subsequent transaction as dirty.
Make any exchange, any vendor, any trader, and any user check with a government database before or immediately after receiving a payment, with penalties prescribed by law.
You immediately limit stolen crypto to the black market.
This will force creation and use of wallet reputation checkers for most users of cryptocurrencies. Mixers will not want to be left holding all the blacklisted coins, since that causes them financial loss. Therefore mixers will launder coins at a very high premium (lemon market) and compete on developing their own systems for reputation checks and escrows to reduce their risk of being left with coins nobody wants.
So money laundering is what makes blockchains valuable?
Mixers will have to change their policies in order to avoid becoming a market for lemons in which everyone loses.
I do not expect governments to worry a tiniest bit about destroying value of an anti-government technology.
If you intentionally involve yourself in money laundering, you can't really complain about your money being blacklisted.
The ledger is public, which makes blacklisting trivial. No legal entity would be able to hold or trade blacklisted coins.
What does this mean? If a single blacklisted coin is put in a mixer then every other coin mixed together is blacklisted? You've just banned mixers. Eventually every single coin will be able to be traced back to a blacklisted wallet, so you've also just effectively banned crypto in the long run.
> No legal entity would be able to hold or trade blacklisted coins.
Mixers don't have to be entities though. No one owns them, no one is responsible for them. They're just code someone uploaded one day and promptly forgot about.
It’s no different to a thief stealing your bike then selling it to someone else on a street corner. Just because that person is the current owner and thinks they legitimately purchased it doesn’t make it rightfully theirs. In fact it’s even worse because it’s trivial to identify who the rightful owner is in this case, and if you buy an NFT you can look back at exactly who has owned it previously.
Now imagine if this was the deeds to your house on the blockchain.
Therefore phishing the seed phrase is not "actually stealing" it within the rules of NFT.
And outside the rules of NFT it's just a receipt; it's worthless. It's taking a picture of a picture of a bike, not stealing it.
If you steal my bike, that's theft. If you steal my DVD collection, that's theft. If you steal my steam account, that's theft. If you steal my NFT, that's theft.
If they did, then the same would apply.
For example, if the court orders you to turn over your Bitcoin holdings to creditors in a bankruptcy proceeding and instead you transfer them elsewhere, you are probably going to jail. When you transferred them, the coins were in your possession, but you weren't the rightful owner.
But NFTs and certain smart contracts are meticulously designing a custom form of ownership for themselves. That's what changes things. And this would be true even if they didn't use blockchains!
If you throw out all that custom ownership logic, you lose the core of what makes an NFT an NFT. Now it's just a few dozen bytes that anyone can mimic.
Not sure what you mean by custom form of ownership. If you are talking about fractional ownership, even that isn’t new.
Contracts around ownership are built on top of legal system. Smart contracts provide automation around defining and execution the contracts. That’s cool and can be super low cost, but apart from the automation, there isn’t much that’s different from traditional contracts. They can still be challenged in court.
For example, if you had a contract that, upon your death, transferred all your money to your nurse, your spouse could still challenge that in court if the contract was created under duress or created when you weren’t of sound mind.
If you get picky about the latter part, then I retract it and just say NFTs for simplicity.
For example, you can write a smart contract that would watch for divorce papers being filed by your spouse and upon filing, you would transfer your Bitcoin balance or NFT to some other wallet. A court isn’t going to fall for that. You will be found to have hidden community assets (ie assets you don’t entirely own).
Another point of comparison I'll bring up is cars, where if you let someone have your keys then you have limited or zero recourse in many situations where they do something bad.
Your car example is a good one. If somebody has your keys (either with permission or stolen) and they take your car, they have possession of it but at no point do they own it.
Another example - lots of companies have crypto wallets and own Bitcoin and other currencies. Corporate wallets are controlled by agents of that company. The people who know the keys don't own the crypto, the company does. If an employee transfers from a company owned wallet that they control to a wallet they own, that's theft the same as if they had wired money to an overseas account of theirs.
Possession and ownership can align, but they don't have to. Smart contracts can be legally binding, but that isn't guaranteed. None of this exists outside of our legal system.
But also I'm saying that a foundational pillar of NFTs is that possession on the blockchain is the only thing that matters.
It's possible to disagree with that pillar, but removing it would destroy a huge chunk of what NFTs are.
If you want me not to say 'ownership' for that concept, that's fine.
Also I'm not making this claim about crytocurrency in general. It's only specific subsets.
This is a situation specific to NFTs and people that are going super hard on smart contracts.
And even if I was a true believer in NFTs, yeah I'd probably ask the courts to do that, but doing so would be a betrayal of my beliefs and evidence that the foundation of NFTs is very shaky. The idea that I would do something hypocritical in such a hypothetical situation doesn't change the argument I made in my previous post.
Or are people banking on another layered solution which has arbitration, disputes, clawbacks, etc - all built within the blockchain. (I remember EOS discussing something like this)
Note: I understand that risk is present in any financial endeavor, but knowing that the courts can help you does de-risk the amount people will feel comfortable investing.
That's just the thing, isn't it? Courts have zero interest in upholding whatever boneheaded ideals that NFTs are meant to represent. Receiving stolen goods is a crime, and that's something courts are entirely geared towards resolving.
Say you hold most of your wealth in some cryptocurrency and are going to file for bankruptcy. Do you think the courts will tell your creditors that the Bitcoin is beyond reach? I suspect they wouldn’t treat it differently from any other asset.
That the blockchain is interpreted as a record of ownership is irrelevant. It merely records what has happened and says nothing about the nature of those transfers.
The cryotocurrency community supports the "code is law" talking point only until serious money is lost. Then they go the courts for redress under actual law, or they fork the blockchain.
--
For the downvotes, I'll add some further explanation: you have access to the keys in order to perform a sale of "your" NFT, but no US court (I am unsure of other countries) has yet ruled in a case that clarifies whether a person actually owns an NFT. For example, they have not ever ruled against someone who has "stolen" an NFT. Therefore, there is no case law that says whether a person legally "owns" an NFT.
Don't just take my word for it:
> Ultimately, an NFT owner has access to the underlying asset, but they may lack exclusive access to or control of the asset, let alone ownership of the asset or any intellectual property (IP).
https://www.lawyer-monthly.com/2021/05/nfts-and-ip-law-who-o...
The specific danger here legally is trying to apply general laws into an unregulated market. It's a bit like borrowing money from your mate and then trying to take him to court because he's asking for too much interest.
They are, or at least purport to be, fair at some level or through some mechanism most people may not immediately percieve.
When something really isn't fair, even by some indirect means or when accounting for some other imperative like geneneral societal necessity, then they are at least understood to be failures not successes.
This story though... it actually provides a good example of indirect fairness. Well yes and no, there's a point and also a counter to that point, net result throw up my hands glad I'm not in crypto:
Point, it's fair: You got robbed and think it's unfair that there's no recourse. That downside is just the fair price of being in that game at all, which you pay in trade for not having to deal with the traditional system and "the man". You have to absorb the occasional loss from a mistake as just a feature of the environment like the risk of your shipping boat sinking because the ocean is not a safe place. The only protection possible is pay an insurer or maintain your own emergency escrow or something, not any kind of police or rule-daddy.
Point, it's not fair: They are not in fact free of the man, and so they are not really getting the true freedom they are paying for by assuming all responsibility for their own risk.
(Rabbit hole because I sense this is a debate lawyers have all through law school, and there are various schools of thoughts about the nature of the law etc)
Yeah, that's by design. If your "notions of fair are often at odds" with someone else's notions of fair, and a judge needs to intervene to resolve the dispute, then things may not break your way.