That is plausible. It can definitely be argued that the segment of the population most vocally in favor the second amendment are the same people most likely to be pro-law enforcement, which reduces the credibility of the tyranny argument.
Similarly, people commonly 'support the troops' yet distrust 'the government' entirely. It's a bizarre duality (to me) but very common.
Note well: In this post, I am not saying that such a position is right, or even sane - merely that it's consistent.