To sum it up, in a two-party system there are three kinds of issues:
- issues which both parties can agree upon (getting fewer and fewer in the US currently).
- issues which benefit one party more than the other, which get polarized, no matter how obvious they seem at first.
- issues which could potentially be bad for both parties, which are not even seriously discussed.
If Democrats stopped being the party of city people, they could compete for that vote.
You don’t see many candidates campaigning in Nebraska instead of Florida
I'm talking about this one:
Nebraska has a 2.0M population and 5 electors = 0.4M people per elector California has a 39M population and 55 electors = 0.7M people per elector.
The US was founded by white supremacist slaveowners taking stolen land through genocide and warfare. Its power structures were designed to maintain that status quo - keeping the white establishment in power while disenfranchising all other groups. That this race-based stratification of power is less overt now as it was in the 18th century isn't relevant, those power structures and the incentives they created still exist and still favor the white establishment. The "rural vs city-dwellers" and "population" debates tend to be proxies for race - the population in urban areas skews nonwhite, the population in rural areas is overwhelmingly white. The American right and the Republican party have, implicitly and explicitly, voiced their concern and fear of losing white power to a demographic shift towards minority status for years.
If that weren't the case, the electoral college would probably have been dumped ages ago. It's arcane and awkward and is only good for that one thing.
While westward expansion did kill many natives at the hands of settlers, not just white, the majority of the native population had already expired long before westward expansion. Diseases introduced by Europeans wiped out an estimated 90% of the native population before the colonies were established. By the time of Manifest Destiny the Americas were empty compared to pre-European contact populations.
Yes, power dynamics have been central to every civilization. And at the time of the founding of the US - as a British colony - the power dynamics of Imperial Britain as well as the US were based on white supremacy, with the colonizing, subjugation and "civilization" of nonwhite societies being an expression of that. Race, relative to both slavery and manifest destiny, was integral to the philosophy and implementation of early American society.
And the US wasn't so empty that the government felt no need to wage the Indian Wars, enact the Indian Removal Act, or push natives onto reservations. Ben Franklin's famous (and often misunderstood) quote about security versus liberty was made in the context of seeking greater Federal power to fend off native attacks. The genocide of a relatively small population is still genocide, but clearly there were still enough natives to be a persistent cause for concern to the colonists.
The history of the US is no different than every other empire that has existed.
Obviously it wasn’t set up to be like this: the GOP just evolved to fill the niche of rural politics to get the power. If anything, maybe there was a bias towards physiocrats vs urban liberals in the founders’ day that now manifests as Red v Blue.
I’m not sure if I can see many first principles justifications for giving rural areas such a mechanism of power, but I also don’t see the entire US being dominated by LA and NYC as a good thing either.
The primary justification to give states such power is that otherwise they might leave the federation. One have to first ask why areas with radically different population density should be governed under the same government, rather than having them rule over themselves.
Two clear examples of non-proportional representation is EU and Iceland. EU has given the 3 smallest nations 6 representative each, which is just a bit less than 1% of the total votes. However if EU used proportional representation they wouldn't even get 1 representative, as the smallest one has less than 0.1% of the population in EU. Germany in contrast holds around 13% of the votes, with about 20% of the total populations.
Iceland has non-proportional representation for a rather obvious reason. Over 51% of people who live in Iceland live in the capital region. A proportional representation democracy would be identical to a dictatorship. In order to avoid this they gave each rural area just enough representatives so that the sum would have more votes than the capital alone. If all rural area went together they decide, but the capital by virtue of being the biggest region still holds the power in practically all situations.
But Iceland has proportional representation. I wonder whether you mean that it doesn't have at-large proportional representation (i.e. only one district). If so, I tend to agree that merging all of the districts would be a backwards step. Having said that, I still believe it would be far from a dictatorship.
Direct voting (popular votes)
State based (like the senate)
The current electoral college is an arbitrary blend of the two where it’s somewhat proportional (states EC count is roughly related to their population*) but also all states get 1 base vote, plus one per senator— resulting in states like Wyoming having 3 votes despite their tiny population, making each Wyoming citizens vote objectively more impactful than the states with populations above the median
Except this isn’t even true— because it doesn’t matter. Since it’s winner takes all, swing states are all that matters to presidential campaigns. If you’re in a small state that is also dominated by one party, your outsized vote still does not matter
The only effect of the electoral college is to overemphasize swing state’s votes.
This is a ridiculous strawman. One person one vote is a good thing, and LA and NYC do not nearly have a majority of the population ... but if they did, then political outcomes should indeed by dominated by the majority vote.
Technically, you also need to figure in the fact that by winning NY and CA it also means that some Republican votes in that popular vote denominator are also removed, so it gets a bit more complicated, but here's the full math if you want to check it.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1haVZVC3iYBOMwCO2ZZia...
Nobody knows how to predict it based on another system, so they're all conservative as in wanting to keep the status quo.
If the voting system changed, there's no telling how many people would start or stop voting based on the new rules.