This doesn't mean every COVID infection is going to cause permanent heart damage for everyone. But increases in heart failure, etc. could definitely be from the massive, nearly unmitigated global spread of COVID-19.
... if you look for something, you'll find it. Test everybody with a pulse for the flu and then track the long term effects the same way we are with covid and I'm sure you'll see a very similar result. It's just nobody gave a shit about it until covid put it on the radar.
edit: And people ARE tracking things like flu vs. COVID statistics. So far COVID-19 is roughly 10x as deadly as a bad flu year. Ten times...
There is so much panic, hysteria and just mythos around covid that I have a hard time believing this. Calling this thing "novel" gave some of these experts a hell of a lot of artistic liberty in how they describe covid.
> And people ARE tracking things like flu vs. COVID statistics. So far COVID-19 is roughly 10x as deadly as a bad flu year. Ten times...
I'm still not fully convinced that due to the massive amount of surveillance we've built around covid, it is even fair to compare the IFR of the flu vs. covid. We've never measured the progress of any virus to this degree. If we tracked the flu the same way we tracked covid, what kinds of numbers would we be getting for that virus?
We have a massive river of data coming in for covid. Vastly more data about it than any other virus in human history. I don't think anybody knows how to process all of it in a way that lets us meaningfully compare it to anything prior.
You clearly are not arguing in good faith or of sound mind.
Of course I'm calling in suspect pretty much every bit of research conducted over the last two years. Nobody had a level head, myself included. It will be at least a decade before things cool down enough to actually look objectively at covid and our mitigations. And I strongly suspect when it is objectively looked at, it will be regarded as one of the worst public health fuckups in human history. Mass hysteria at a level never before possible.
However in this case, I am pretty damn sure history will be on my side. Absolutely none of what we did over the last two years made a lick of sense. It is the first real mass hysteria of the internet age.
"For the second year, COVID-19 was the third leading cause of death after heart disease and cancer."
It is no exaggeration to say that COVID is a significant cause of death and threat to the health of the public. Only two things kill more people a year--heart disease and cancer. Not car accidents, not gun violence, not suicides... all those kill far fewer people than COVID.
And yet two years into this I've yet to hear a solid answer to "is it 'died with' or 'died from'?" It's kind of funny that there is no answer to that because it dramatically changes how to interpret your figure.
All these "experts" just skirt right around that question and asking it gets you labeled as a horrible alt-right grandma killer (which isn't hyperbole either, I've literally been called this multiple times).
Not only that, but in 2021 sweden had the lowest excess mortality in the entirety of Europe.
So let's not pretend the math is simple here. Social disruption is lethal to vulnerable demographics. Even daylight savings time changes notoriously cause a large surge in heart attacks.
In the US, it seems rather unlikely that (a) doctors all over the US report a certain number of deaths that they say were caused by covid, and (b) we have about that many excess deaths, BUT (c) the excess deaths were from other causes and just happened to match the number of reported covid deaths.
People die with cancer too, but few people are quite perverse enough to take that as evidence that the threat posed by cancer is exaggerated. Possibly the only comparable level of denial about the causal relationship between a well known ailment and people who don't normally die being likely to die afterwards for reasons well-explained by how that ailment affects the body I can think of is HIV/AIDs, and it's not coincidental that one's highly politicised too.
https://i.imgur.com/bjWZS81.png
https://ourworldindata.org/covid-stringency-index
oh and here are some excess deaths you can compare across norway sweden and denmark - the difference is negligible - and this image doesn't even include 2021 where sweden had literally the lowest excess death in europe
https://preview.redd.it/u8etorcogu451.png?width=756&format=p...
Your excess deaths chart shows Sweden's rising by 5,000 people from 2019 to 2020, while Norway and Denmark's fell.
This image (https://ars.els-cdn.com/content/image/1-s2.0-S01688510210022...) from this study (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S016885102...) is a direct refutation of your argument.
If you actually care about the subject feel free to look it up yourself, don't take my word for it as the measurements are all open source on github, including the methodology used to calculate the index.
To be clear, I don't think it's all made up. Just that it's been blown up, completely out of proportion. All of it.
> Just that it's been blown up, completely out of proportion
No, not precisely. Others have seen dozens. Still getting conversation lines like "I called that former colleague since it's been years... His wife told me he went, lungless, two years ago, at the beginning of the whole thing". Similarly for other more recent matters (it's not important to go in details here).
It was not really "blown completely out of proportion", more like "very badly managed, communicationally, procedurally, juridically, strategically, civilly, socially" - in some areas.
A serious matter dealt with clumsily, mindlessly and hysterically.
https://academic.oup.com/cid/advance-article/doi/10.1093/cid... https://www.thestandard.com.hk/breaking-news/section/4/17917...
But you know. Correlation is not causation! The vaccines are just as safe and effective as promised! Oh, wait, not effective. They're safe though! Trust us, we're the government, we wouldn't lie!
Some countries experienced essentially no excess death even without vaccines, and some experienced non-Covid attributed excess death independent of vaccines. You really can’t read anything off excess death, except that it exists (where it exists)
I leave it to you as to whether you think 1 million deaths over 2 years in the US is something you should have been fearful of, or whether it is pretty trivial
What part of "I don't doubt the statistics." did you not understand?
> "I leave it to you as to..."
Oh gee, thanks your permission to think for myself.
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanam/article/PIIS2667-19...
https://twitter.com/DrEricDing/status/1495025615178768384?s=...
*and the great majority of those cases unsurprisingly were among the unvaccinated
It paints a similar picture. A lot more people "than usual" dying in 2020 (before vaccines in US).
https://www.wsj.com/articles/omicron-deaths-in-u-s-exceed-de...
… and yes the ONS is independent of government
Heart disease has been the leading cause of death (mostly for men over 30 and women over 60) for a very long time [1].
According to [2] and [3] the world's number of deaths by cardiac illness was about a million people larger in 2021 than in 2017, but because of the delayed effect that heart issues can have we might not be able to see the true increase the last year has had until it's well behind us.
The sad fact is that a lot of us are going to die of a heart problem we didn't even know we had. And since heart health is affected by so many things it's very difficult to find a single root cause for it in anybody. That said there's already research showing that cases of arrhythmia and atrial fibrillation are increased in people who had covid within 1 year of contracting it [4]. Which makes sense because heart problems increase in people who contract many life threatening illnesses, such as certain types of cancer [5].
Our hearts take hits from just about everything that happens to us and everything we do, and our means of identifying, preventing, curing, or (someday I hope) reversing heart illness is still far behind where it needs to be. Please remember to get physicals at the recommended pace for your age group (ask your doctor) and try to do things to get your heart pumping in a good way when you can.
[1] https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsde...
[2] https://deadorkicking.com/death-statistics/worldwide/2018/
[3] https://deadorkicking.com/death-statistics/worldwide/2021/
[4] https://publichealth.jhu.edu/2022/covid-and-the-heart-it-spa...
[5] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28618843/
edit: some grammar
If you're paranoid that your particular country is manipulating data, look at some other developed country's data.
[1] https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/ontario-is-changing-how-it-report...
That so many of these "experts" dance around this question and shame the person asking it has made me very, very suspect of their motives.
People only pay more attention to.
There were a lot more sudden deaths in football in 2021 than in any other year.
Could be:
1. Increased sudden heart failure due to Covid
2. Increased sudden heart failure due to vaccines
3. No increase in sudden heart failure, but in 2021 we observed and catalogued cases more meticulously than ever
4. Something else, unrelated to covid or vaccines
https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-coronavirus-sport/...
https://www.reuters.com/article/factcheck-coronavirus-fifa/f...
And between 2014-2018 617 footballers died according to FIFA SDR, that's 123 per year. The Wikipedia list is pretty short for that years, because nobody cared to enter them on Wikipedia.
That's a claim not supported by your link. Recency bias (and perhaps a greater media and Wiki-editing focus following a player suffering non-fatal cardiac arrest on the pitch in the World Cup) means there are more listed names in 2021.
But the article also points out that FIFA investigated 617 deaths over a previous 5 year period, which implies far, far more deaths in regular years than itemised on Wikipedia...
My only claim is that Wikipedia catalogues a lot more sudden deaths in Football in 2021.
You have repeated possibility #3 of my comment:
> 3. No increase in sudden heart failure, but in 2021 we observed and catalogued cases more meticulously than ever
"3. No increase in sudden heart failure, but in 2021 we observed and catalogued cases more meticulously than ever"
but I am not sure anymore who is more stupid the anti vaxxer or the vaxx worshipper who will down vote and be against anything that could hint at the vaccines not being perfect.
This is the part that is wrong. There not more sudden deaths in football 2021, there are just more entries on the wiki page for the year 2021. Between 2014 and 2018 617 players died according to the FIFA SDR, but the wiki page is rather short for that years.
Data from 40 health care systems participating in a large network found that the risk for cardiac complications was significantly higher after SARS-CoV-2 infection than after mRNA COVID-19 vaccination for both males and females in all age groups.