The service is making them available. You have to pay a premium for this service. If it wasn't for scalpers, then you (probably) just wouldn't get one, unless you're waiting in line for the store to open.
Trying to regulate away this problem will just lead to more "innovative" scalpers.
if anything microsoft's plan of offering two sku's lowering the price has been more effective
How's that? If that's what people are already actually buying them for, then people can already afford them.
Supposedly, the world is more complicated than some stuff you picked up from Econ 101.