There's no way that characterizes Austin. It's a sprawly city. Anyone who even tries to go car free there will be disappointed.
why do they need to exist?
they are even harder to maintain than suburbs, have you not noticed the meter thick layer of dirt in the NYC subway?
NYC public transportation has all the usual problems, but it moves a lot of people who otherwise would not be able to move. (this is basically why it's so "full of crazy people, but it's not a cause it's an effect of the efficiency of NYC)