This, I hope, is another step we take towards near-eradication of genetic diseases. And good riddance
This, I hope, is another step we take towards near-eradication of genetic diseases. And good riddance
All that said, once people are born they deserve the digity to decide themselves whether they live or die. With a lot of help and emotional support before making any permanent choices.
Before people are born parent's likewise should have as much information as possible before they have to make a permanent choice for someone else. IMO that should include the option to abort a pregnancy very likely to lead to a lifetime of suffering.
So are many atheists, I grew up with some myself.
>Converting educated adults is an uphill battle
I'm assuming by educated adults, you mean atheists. Converting educated religious adults to atheism is also an uphill battle. Perhaps that, like my previous post, says more about the nature of people than about atheism/ theism.
Rise of agnosticism and atheism also motivates them to action. After all these are eternal souls bound to suffer forever in flames and darkness.
This doesn’t make any sense to me (assuming you are not being sarcastic). Does it make sense that Joseph Stalin and Random Joe (who was a good person, but wasn’t truly A, B, C) would both suffer equal fates? What about a person who lived thousands of years ago deep in a jungle and didn’t even have an opportunity? It doesn’t make any sense.
What criteria are you using to make this judgement?
> towards near-eradication of genetic diseases
My concern would be that we might be unable to distinguish useful genetic adaptations from disease. How do we actually make these decisions? Examine the DNA and then look for SNPs of concern? Is that a perfect process, or one dominated by statistics? How likely is it that this method will arrive at the expected goal?
We sort of do this at a high level and with less empiricism anyways. We are often trained what characteristics in a mate we find attractive and use selection based on those attributes or make our own independnet choices, discarding these trends. Sometimes we make good choices, sometimes we make bad choices.
The concern I would have more here is that the decision process would be fairly standardized and start to lack diversity more than us making the "wrong" choices as we currently do. We're going to make the wrong choices, period, because we don't have a crystal ball to predict all future cases where some attributes we deem harmful turn out to be more useful.
The way we currently fight this and thrive is through a wide degree of diversity in the selection amd decision process, allowing for a fairly wide diversity of attributes. If the process becomes methodical, we're likely to start converging on fewer and fewer "acceptable" mutations. If we're advanced enough that we somehow can tell good and bad genetic attributes from a survival standpoint then maybe this isn't terrible but I think that is a challenging problem in and of itself. Just assume you can arbitrarily change human attributes around, what is the ideal human?
Then we have the social implications. All of this reminds me of the movie GATACCA.
For a good example of where this can wrong and have unintended side effects, look at the babies that had their genetics edited with CRISPR by He Jiankui. Their genes were edited to make them less susceptible to HIV, yet that genetic modification has biological consequences[1][2] outside of preventing HIV, as the edited gene coded for a receptor protein on cells.
Many factors were overlooked when doing the gene editing[2], and the kids' genes were edited both incorrectly and not optimally. The edits also affect their germline, meaning that their future kids could potentially inherit similar genetic errors.
As a result, the HIV susceptibility "benefit" might not actually be so beneficial, and even if it was, there are strains of HIV that don't use that receptor protein as vector for infection, as well. Research has even suggested that they might be more susceptible to HIV, now, and that their particular mutations could result in shorter lifespans than people without the mutations.
I wouldn't feel too well about having my genome botched for profit before I was even born, learning that I have an outdated version of an edited gene that might kill me, and being told that my kids would potentially inherit some alpha version of a gene that doesn't even work right. The same feelings would apply to lab selected natural mutations, as well.
I think we're at a stage where we do not have a complete, or even satisfactory, understanding of our genome and biology, and the same goes for both our understanding of gene editing and selection, and their consequences. For example, we have a very primitive understanding of how the brain works, and editing, or selecting, genes that are expressed in the nervous system could have serious deleterious effects, which is something that is hypothesized to have accidentally happened with the CRISPR twins[3].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CCR5#Potential_costs
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/He_Jiankui_affair#Scientific_b...
[3] https://www.technologyreview.com/2019/02/21/137309/the-crisp...
I was a pro-abortion rally (as a supporter of abortion) and an old man asked me, “Aren’t you glad your mother didn’t abort you?” And I told him “not really.”
It is dangerous to make such decisions in advance on behalf of people not yet born. My wife was born in the 1980s with a rather problematic heart condition. She is now completely fine aside from a few things she cannot do. I am glad that she is alive and that we were able to meet.
Also with the soon revocation of Roe vs Wade, what is the reason for this testing, other than to increase the health insurance costs for you children?
Youre not more likely to be a genius if you have ALS so might as well roll the dice with someone with less health problems.
What if your parents found out when you were 12 months old? Would you wish that they had euthanised you at that age, before you were really self-aware, and before they got too emotionally attached to (or financially invested in) you?
The point of my thought experiment, though, was not to imagine what a parent would do, but what someone with a terminal diagnose would wish their parents had done.
I accept that this is not an easy thing to talk about, nor are there any easy answers, so I'm not trying to start an argument. If someone wants to think about it, they can, and it's just a difficult hypothetical that came to my mind when I read the original comment.
Not as hard as losing a one-year-old, I'm pretty sure, but also not just a blip.