Except they are, themselves, a new dependency. And might even introduce more dependencies themselves.
Also, is writing your own scripts to symlink appropriate dot files across different environments not also a new dependency?
I mean we’re talking about Linux dotfiles. At worst, you might need a binary for arm, if amd64 isn’t enough. I’m not clear on your point about ABI incompatibility for simple binaries.
Like, i think its best to wait like, 10 years, and see how the whole thing worked out. Maybe we need another systemd or two until people realize that software is still a liability even if you aren't the one who is maintaining it.