California court finds that bees fall under classification defined by legal text is a more appropriate headline.
California court finds that bees fall under classification defined by legal text is a more appropriate headline.
Now, there are terrestrial invertebrates as well, for instance, bees. No reasonable person would think that the legislature meant to include terrestrial invertebrates into the definition of fish. But, that's what this judge did, giving the absurd result that bees are fish.
Nobody who actually read the decision could be left with the impression that this is about what "reasonable people" would understand the term "fish" to be, because that's not remotely what the statute itself says.
Here's what the judge should have said. "In this part of the law, 'invertebrate' refers to a fish. In other parts of the law, 'invertebrate' refers to terrestrial animals. Obviously, the legislature did not mean to include terrestrial animals as fish. Therefore, a bee is not a fish".
In October 2018, the public interest groups
petitioned the Commission to list four species of
bumble bee as endangered species: the Crotch
bumble bee, the Franklin bumble bee, the Suckley
cuckoo bumble bee, and the Western bumble bee
(collectively the four bumble bee species)
[... 2 grafs ...]
In September 2019, petitioners challenged the
Commission’s decision by filing a petition for
writ of administrative mandate in the trial
court. Petitioners asserted the Commission’s
determination that the four bumble bee species
qualify for listing as candidate species under the
Act “violated the Commission’s legal duty, was a
clear legal error, and was an abuse of
discretion.”
There's a bunch of problems with the argument that California can't legally designate bugs as endangered species, one of which is that the act was amended specifically to protect endangered butterflies in the first place, the other of which is that it would be an insane result.It's an easy opinion to read. You can just get this from the document linked on the thread. It's all right there.
No, the judge took examples from other areas of the law as evidence against the argument that the Legislature could not have intended what the plain language of the definition in the section of the law in dispute directly says. The definition was not taken from a different section of law, only evidence against the effort to reinterpret the definition in a narrower way than it's plain language suggests.
> We acknowledge the scope of the definition is ambiguous but also recognize we are not interpreting the definition on a blank slate. The legislative history supports the liberal interpretation of the Act (the lens through which we are required to construe the Act) that the Commission may list any invertebrate as an endangered or threatened species.
> (the lens through which we are required to construe the Act)
> through which we are required
Take it up with Sacramento!