What I think a lot of people are learning is that a lot of these "shortages" and supply chain issues are entirely opportunistic and artificial. Prices are going up because prices are going up.
What I think a lot of people are learning is that a lot of these "shortages" and supply chain issues are entirely opportunistic and artificial. Prices are going up because prices are going up.
Why? Lockdowns! Suddenly people had a lot more time on their hands, a lot less places available to spend their money and everyone around me decided on some kind of a construction/renovation/... project. This made people buy more construction materials (cement, tiles, lumber too) and combined with some supply chain issues, prices skyrocketed. A friend of mine was building an "open garage" (slab of cement, four poles, roof, and an overhang to put a "picnic table" there too), and had to buy cement four times during a month-long diy project, and each time, the price was higher (all in the same month).
Here we're talking about lumber and the supply chain is fairly straihtforward.
Trees are felled somewhere. They could be planted for that purpose (fun fact: almost all paper comes from trees grown for that purpose, which complicates the story of recycling) or they could be in the wild. These places are typically remote.
Trucks then take these trees to sawmills to be processed. That could be nearby or it could be far.
The products from those sawmills then typically go to lumber yards. The sawmill itself might operate a lumber yard. Or you might have intermediate distributors. In the US a lot of lumber goes through Atlanta for various reasons.
It then gets shipped again to retailers (eg Home Depot) and to builders, pretty much all by truck.
So this supply chain is relatively simple. YOu need labour at several points (eg lumberjacks, sawmill operators, truck drivers), trucks to drive material around, gas for the trucks and land to store products.
So if a handful of players own the sawmills and/or lumberyards when demand upticks you can create a supply issue simply by withholding supply at one of these steps. Maybe you don't open a sawmill or two. Maybe you don't employ people to move lumber from the sawmill to lumberyards. You just stockpile it while the price goes up.
If you look into lumber specifically it's fairly clear that "hoarding" is what was happening. Other shortages may or may not be similar.
Tangent: That just blows my mind how that can be a thing. The trees take like, 20 years to be harvestable? And lumber at the source isn't that expensive? So, how can it be profitable to buy land and guard/maintain the trees for 20 years before you get any profit?
* This is a point of contention for the US government because they feel that the Canadian lumber industry is government-subsidized and unfairly competes with US lumber producers. As a result, the US applies import taxes on Canadian lumber.
This has been going on for decades:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canada–United_States_softwood_...
It's like a pipeline -- yes it might take 20 years to grow a patch to harvest quality, but you have 100 of these patches and only harvest 5 a year. By the time you get around to needing to reharvest patch #1 it'll have been 20 years and it will have regrown.
It's not without a bit of truth. We do build homes much more cheaply and without the assumption that the home will last 200 years. It's a side effect of massive land resources and cheap material costs that Europe doesn't have. We're also a really new country in comparison, and much of our growth occurred during the rise of the automobile and massive roadworks construction, so building a cheap building fast out in the sticks is not only viable, it's attractive.
Long term this is folly, as it depends on cheap energy. But all that said, a properly constructed home from wood studs with plywood sheathing and gypboard internal walls isn't intrinsically shoddy. It's actually very strong and very light, and in large parts of the US, entirely appropriate. Modern engineered wood is amazing stuff.
Traditional masonry is a very poor choice if you're expecting earthquakes.
In Japan (another earthquake-prone area) the classic houses also tended to be lumber and even paper, not masonry, because lightweight materials are less likely to squash you like a bug when the next earthquake comes along.
Obviously the Japanese did use masonry for fortifications and suchlike, but not usually for a standard dwelling.
If you live in the Bay Area all of those things are fairly easy to fix - even as a DIY project. Install more concrete anchors in the sill plates, add earthquake rated connections to beams (which were often just toe-nailed), and put plywood on interior garage walls and half height supporting walls which makes those walls much stiffer (old building standards didn't require nearly as much blocking or cross-bracing between studs).
As long as a wood stick construction structure stays connected to its foundation and has the smallest bit of strength it can withstand even massive earthquakes without issue.
My parents' 50-year-old house has the original drywall and has probably been repainted only once, and it's in remarkably good shape. And that's saying something, given that my parents raised 9 children in that house, and who knows how many before us. The biggest problem is the metal nail-on corner beads in high-flow areas going into the kitchen where it gets lots of abuse and the mud has cracked in a few spots, but modern paper-faced plastic beads solve that problem.
Sure you can use thicker stock than the bare minimum, or double it up for rated firewalls. I've seen such, and such walls do provide good sound isolation between apartments. Ultimately yes, a material is just a material. But it's like OSB versus plywood - you can build cheap or quality things with either, but there's certainly a correlation for what types of things get built with each one.
I'm sure there's some survivorship bias - the cheaper plaster jobs probably fell apart before I was born. But none of this really changes the overarching critique of being in a cheap ranch-box, and hearing everything else going on in the house.
(And for sound transmission I don't think it's the thickness itself, but rather the hardness creating more of an impedance mismatch with the air).
This is because they don't use exterior sheathing for some reason, just building paper.
Load bearing inner walls consist of cheap bricks or concrete. Other inner walls are usually gypsum.
The inside wall is concrete, same as outside.
Wood is used for the roof, though.
For apartment buildings, most built during the socialist era, reinforced concrete was used everywhere, even for internal walls, so drilling between rooms to pull an ethernet cable through was a pain in the ass.
Not really, or rather, the issues were/are region-specific. There were multiple problems, the chief one being that lumber yards have closed down. A sudden-ish shift towards construction usage of wood combined with an excess of raw wood from storm damages [1] then led to a crunch effect at the lumber yards, they were the bottleneck.
On top, there was a serious shortage of truck drivers across Europe caused by the pandemic and shit wages, which meant that even if yards had capacity there was no way to get trees into lumber yards and finished wood products out of them.
[1] https://www.weser-kurier.de/landkreis-osterholz/ueberangebot...
My take is that the supply chain for lumber, as with e.g. toilet paper, is optimised for a particular, and until 2020 relatively stable, level of output. The last two years have changed all that, and demand has outstripped supply, which has led to an increase in prices.
Without government intervention any "free market" will quickly devolve into a monopoly or oligopoly. We end up with price cartels as is that we constantly need to regulate and break up.
You really don't have to look far to see what happens with weak or no government oversight in a "free market". Look at Chevron pollution in Ecuador. Look at the baby formula "shortage". Look at the ludicrous and unjustifiable price for insulin in the US. Look at the artifically high pricing on mined diamonds and the de Beers cartel. Look at the fact that most eyeglass frames are made by a single company.
1) Ecuadorian govt lost in international courts and us courts. Overall this case is irrelevant to free markets either way, but it's quite believable that it's a post factum shakedown attempt by a corrupt govt.
2) baby formula is extremely regulated. The factory was shut down by the govt, market is hard to enter due to regulation, imports are very restricted by the govt, even e.g. from Europe.
3) Insulin is the same story - govt restricts imports AND production. Intellectual property regime (which I d argue is one of the few good things the govt does - but it has nothing to do with free markets) is also at fault, although as far as I understand less so for insulin, perhaps for newer products. Not even getting into overall healthcare incentives screwed up by govt action (employer based health insurance, etc.).
4) dunno much about diamond, but I'm going to assume the example is just as bogus as the others.
5) I got great frames online for like $35 (there were cheaper ones too, didn't look as nice); my prescription is very high so these were not Walmart checkout glasses, either. Free market in action! I sure hope govt doesn't regulate it and force me back to local price gouging optometrist again, "for my own safety"!
You can argue some hoarding is motivated by fear, but a lot of it is motivated by greed. I know friends working in the construction business claiming some people just upfront bought whole stocks cement during the pandemic for example.
Probably a lot of these purchases are done with funny money because money was being thrown around for cheap. So I'd imagine people would ask a higher price because funny money allowed to pay those prices, all due to the greedy hoarding behavior - at the end of the funnel people were paying stupid prices for housing for example, so why not?
That same friend also said that they simply had to go and buy it from the secondary market for a premium.
How do you solve this problem in the future? Are quotas the solution?
It's only "despicable" if an individual does it. But "gains advantage" when you're a company.
See: https://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/28/business/worldbusiness/28...
No, doubling down on a centrally planned economy is not the solution.
The solution is to stop printing trillions of dollars and aimlessly injecting them into the financial industry. Make interest rates exist again (say 5%), so that investments have to make sense. And let the asset bubbles actually pop for once, so people stop trying to create their own DIY asset classes out of consumer goods.
It’s not despicable, it’s risk adjusting by carrying inventory. (If you inventory more than you can use, and it’s perishable, it’s a different problem.)
In a localized market, people adjusted their risk by stocking up toilet paper, canned goods, etc. Those who couldn't afford it, or came too late, were left with nothing.
In a globalized market those who have access to free money can hoard as much of it as they want.
As a consequence it spreads like a disease.
You may say, in the case of the USA: "well, I guess that's the perks of being in control of the standard currency for global transactions, the rest just has to deal with it" -> this won't end up well for anyone.
Billionaires hoarding toilet paper isn't a problem. It's everyday folk. Same for practically any other thing where hoarding is blamed. When we're calling the dispersed response of hundreds of millions of people despicable, it's the system--not people--that is broken.
How do you tackle this? Like I said in my original comment - will we have to resort to quotas?
Who is hoarding processors? The predominant driver of the current shortage is the auto industry pulling orders in the early pandemic and then raging back into gear. The only people stockpiling are groups like Huawei, and they aren't "hoarding" nearly enough to influence global prices.
Broadly speaking, when a politician blames hoarding, it's a dead giveaway for deflecting from a systemic issue. The culprit is usually price gouging laws, which discourage holding emergency reserves. In this case, it was just a global supply chain system stressed by demand dynamism and stimulus spending.