- bots, as you say
- "legit" bots e.g. customer service
- inactive accounts
- accounts that use some alternate client (tweetdeck or whatever)
- API users
- possibly web accounts using ad block (depending on whether twitter measures literal ad views vs. "users logging in with a client that could show ads"
- ...
> Elon could be right that over half of Twitter's users are fake, and Twitter could be right that only 5% of the MDAUs are fake. While both could be right in their assertions, Elon is in the wrong in the big picture. All of this has been disclosed publicly and Twitter never claims that only 5% of users are bots, just 5% of monetizable users. Elon's claims of malfeasance or obfuscation are wrong.
That's exactly my conclusion as well
It's hard to have 100% confidence in Twitter's ability to classify bots accurately for mDAU purposes, given their terrible accuracy for anti-spam purposes. It's a slightly different problem (because ads can be counted after the fact while anti-spam has to be immediate) but it raises enough doubt about the mDAU numbers that I'd want to see more data.
Also, when buying public companies, you have to be extremely careful not to let word get out before it's publicly announced. It's easy to imagine a Twitter employee tasked with sending logs to E.M. Acquisition Corp leaking this particular bombshell to the press.
So it's normal to make an acquisition bid based only on their publicly reported numbers. The acquisition contract provides for a due-diligence phase that happens between when the deal is announced and when it's final (ie, now) where the buyer can verify that there aren't material misrepresentations in the public filings. If there are, they can back out.
Everything about this process is normal, except the hyperventilating press.
It would have been reasonable to dig into during due diligence, but Musk waived due diligence.
Here is Elon Musk responding to that thread with a poop emoji: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1526246899606601730
The problem isn't that no one has bridged this divide, it's that Elon Musk is acting in bad faith to derail the deal that he fucked up by signing. There's no point talking about spam accounts because that's literally not the issue. The issue is that Musk signed a deal valuing Twitter at a premium at the peak of the market with no real escape clauses, and since there are no legitimate ways for him to renegotiate he needs to come up with a pretense.
Money has amazing perception bending properties.
Four months ago, Musk wanted to destroy Twitter by starting a competitor. Two months ago he wanted to buy it, now he wants to back out of the deal.
Seems to me a dance is taking place.