In Immortal Cosmetics are locked to one character. PoE cross character, remind able, and serve as trophies between leagues.
That's not to mention the breaking of the mold to a near open world versus instanced. Which drives FOMO. As well how the transactions are gamified.
Why people dislike p2w games is that it directly effects gameplay via inflation of grind.
It is nit good game design. Good profit making sure, but at some point you have to admit that these studios pull talent from Vegas.
Be fair. This is an obligation of major studios to make as much profit as possible. However is this short term versus long term? Will the make the needed profit to make up for the lack of trust in the long run?