It does not have to be perfect to be meaningful.
It is deceptive though, if this number is not representative of people's actual cost of living and it is then used to adjust their income for inflation. How clear is it that this basket really represents an average household (today)?
Employer: "What do you mean, cost of living has gone up by 14%? Official inflation is 7%, but the best I can do this year is 3.5%."
Politician: "Inflation is X every year, so we increase pensions by X% every three years."
So I agree with you, but the problem is that it is arbitrary, and the arbiters could be rigging the outcome with their choices.
If not using basics like food, fuel, and pricing on rent or mortgage - what are we basing the numbers off of? If it's the stable price of a Spotify subscription, rather than real goods needed to survive, something is horribly off.
and for the US: https://www.bls.gov/cpi/tables/relative-importance/home.htm
The weights are based on estimates of how consumers actually spend on different goods and services, rather than on how much someone would need to spend for subsistence or survival.
Sure bread is still roughly the same as it was. But living costs have absolutely exploded recently, and far far beyond the 9% indicated.
That seems... unlikely.
https://www.globalpetrolprices.com/United-Kingdom/gasoline_p...
At best it doubled, but that's not the same as "increased by 200%", which implies it tripled.
Historically for me real inflation is the formal EU number + 2%. So that means that they're usually about a 100% off as inflation has been low for a long time, until now.
If the cost of meat goes up so much that everyone starts eating dog food, the inflation print will barely rise at all.
It's not a real measure for QoL which I hope most people would accept as being what societies actually strive for.
In fact most measures like GDP and a few others have no real bearing on increased living standards. GDP per capita should be the only real number when talking about economic growth for starters. Even then catastrophes like natural disasters and war bump up those numbers due to rebuilding so it's still quite a rough metric to report on each year.
It's done because factually consumers buy different and producers produce different things over the years, and it's hard to impossible to observe/measure which substitutions are by necessity and which by preference.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_index#Paasche_and_Laspey...
There's always an implicit older == smarter bias in society but I doubt many people who passed with good grades in high school economics are good at the basic concepts into their 30's.
Not to mention the MMT experiments that have been undertaken in the west over the last few years. I'm not even sure MMT proponents understand the consequences of such things. There's been a lot of resource misallocation that no one seems able to take responsibility for.
GDP, inflation, interest rates, etc are oft considered the main KPI's for politicians by the people who vote for them. It's a dismal science even for those well versed in its ways.
But most kids and adults alike probably find textbook economics and statistics as appealing as unsweetened oatmeal, and strongly prefer to consume sensationalized headlines and conspiracy theories. There's some tension between free choice and paternalistically nudging/forcing the population towards healthier stuff, that I wouldn't know how to resolve.