This is a ridiculous logical fallacy. People want a car or a phone that works. Outside of a few hackers and geeks, nobody cares if they can load their own custom software on it.
This is a ridiculous logical fallacy. People want a car or a phone that works. Outside of a few hackers and geeks, nobody cares if they can load their own custom software on it.
However, when people purchase a small computer, it's reasonable to assume that the ability to modify the software on it is something that could define "ownership", just the way car tinkerers own their cars and show that by fiddling around with the insides.
However, if you do certain mods, said car is no longer street legal.
> Your analogy fails because nobody has any expectation of replacing or changing the software in a car
Not so fast. There are lots of folks who want to change the engine control software, specifically the software related to engine performance. There's even an industry that serves (and sometimes cheats) such people.
Does Apple claim that jail breaking is breaking the law or breaking a contract?
FWIW, the car companies do go after (some) folks who produce "mods" on intellectual property grounds. They haven't yet gone after users but there doesn't seem to be any any reason why they couldn't, using exactly the same reasoning as Apple.
> It's completely unanalogous.
It may not be exactly the same, but there are significant similarities.
In both cases, we have IP claims and (some) users want to "not manufacturer" software mods.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IOS_jailbreaking#United_States_...
Apple claimed it was illegal under the DMCA. They were shot down, and now only claim it voids the warranty.
> It may not be exactly the same, but there are significant similarities.
Don't defend broken analogies. And yes, it is broken. They're supposed to help in making a point, not prove it, anyways.
Since apple isn't claiming a law violation, the only remaining difference is that some people don't know about chipping cars. Is that a serious problem?
They were. Steve Jobs and everyone who still works at Apple would have been okay with it if you were in prison for tinkering with your iPad.
That's an argument that the analogy didn't work before. We're talking about now.
Even if your analogy didn't stink, and it does, it would still be meaningless because it's just a thing you said, not a validated and useful model. So give it up.
I didn't, but there isn't a lot of diversity in the iPhone mods. The vast majority are jailbreaking whereas the car mods change behavior.
> it would still be meaningless because it's just a thing you said, not a validated and useful model.
Validated? It's just as "validated" as iPhone jail breaking.
In fact, since some car mods can result in illegal behavior, not just IP violations, ....
Which reminds me - why is it so important to you that iPhone mods be considered "rad", "sticking it to the man", unique, etc?
Likewise, the first time a customer tries to make a phone call and instead gets a pop up ad saying "YOUR PHONE IS AT RISK!!!!1!!!11!1!" you will know you failed at delivering a successful smartphone experience.
To most people, ownership means legal control over physical possession, and the right to transfer 'ownership'. Apple can't legally require that I return my iPhone to them, just as Toyota can't legally require that I return my minivan to one of their dealers. They 'belong' to me - I 'own' them and control who possesses them.
we'll talk in several years when it will be implantable devices and in several years more when they will be integrated into you neural circuitry and you will be under impression that these thoughts and memories are yours... well, until the DRM allows you to have that impression :) One can easily extrapolate how, like your photos today, Facebook will also have the right to use your dreams in promotional ad campaings.