That’s a lot of conditions, so IMO they don’t make all that much sense and I much prefer RSUs (maybe I’d think differently as a founder). Plus there are sharp edges like AMT. I’ve been an early employee multiple times at companies that had successful exits and never successfully had all conditions satisfied, and have ended up paying regular income tax rates but had more complicated taxes to file.
If joining a company as a non-founder I’d just take straight RSUs.
RSUs are just shares you don't own yet. When you hit your vesting dates, you don't have to DO anything, they just become yours. You don't have to pay anything to execute and often the company will sell some for you to pay the taxes on them.
I wouldn't say one is definitively better.. there are tradeoffs:
RSUs can be better because you don't have to spend money to get them and they're liquid immediately (or at least soon).
Stock options can be better because your pre-IPO price may be better than the public price but you have no guarantee they'll ever be liquid.
- Stock options are "cheaper" for a startup to give out than RSUs, so you get more shares, ie your equity is higher-leverage. So if things go well, you end up with much much more money than had you gotten RSUs (and yes obviously if things go terribly, you get nothing).
Is this generally true? I’m not sure it applies for the typical engineer joining a larger company (a Databricks or Stripe, say) where you’re not really affecting the cap table all that much. Do companies really give out more options than RSUs?
My one personal piece of anecdata here is when considering an offer from a startup (that I didn’t take), they offered during negotiations to change the mix of RSU+options into just all RSUs (same total number).