Biological systems are complex and chaotic. Denying this so that "any old model will do" is pseudoscience; and we should start calling this out.
Biological systems are complex and chaotic. Denying this so that "any old model will do" is pseudoscience; and we should start calling this out.
However in the case of "learning", we're talking about the macro and micro physical structure of the brain encoding vast amounts of sensory-motor models of its environment, etc. We're talking about the brain-body-environment as the site of mood, emotion, desire, belief, imagination, etc. We're talking about that thing when given vallium (a simple chemical effect) has extremely complex net effects on mood, desire, belief, etc.
Inasmuch as CO2 has likewise, extremely complex effects.
The statement that the relevant actions of the brain-body system here are complex is scientifically uncontroversial. Yet, pseudoscience continues -- because some researchers ignore (or are ignorant) of the methodological implications.
It's amazing the confidence people have
The climate was an analogy to illustrate the point
They're both complex because they meet the definition of a complex system
Are they? Seems they are extraordinarily stable. Tortoises can last two centuries, that's not the signature of chaos. What do you mean by that word?
Chaos: When the present determines the future, but the approximate present does not approximately determine the future.
Lorenz
A tortoise alive now is 99.995% likely to be alive tomorrow, if external threats are removed.
Pretty sure that is not the behaviour of chaos under your definition.
That doesn't mean that the triple pendulum isn't a chaotic system. It just shows the chaotic nature of the system doesn't manifest at the level of detail you're considering.
“if external threats are removed” is an attempt to linearize, and therefore remove chaotic behavior. Sometimes you can pull this off and have a reasonable model at the end; sometimes you cannot. This tells you more about your model than it does about the system you’re studying.
By that you could say all is chaotic. We lack a suitable definition here.
Sure. So what?