It's a false dichotomy imo. White paper is really comfortable and it's effectively grey next to a computer screen. That will be a trend one day (I hope). Not enough good middle-value themes with nice unsaturated colors.
solarized light remains the king imo. been using it for almost a decade and while I aesthetically prefer other color schemes I always end up back on it because it's the most comfortable for long periods.
I find Apple’s TrueTone works pretty well. Adjusting the screen based on the light in the room. The idea behind it is to have the screen react more like paper.