The reason I use it is because it checks the git repo of the package out so I can jump in and edit it and be inside a git repo if I wanted to open a PR with my change. When you use package.el it will download .tar's and not have git history inside it.
Edit: Also because of above, straight makes it easy to check out specific branches - this isn't easy using package.el - your packages are pinned to a version - whereas this makes it super easy to just checkout a branch someone made without waiting for a new release.