Entertaining the even more nuanced idea that someone else has a strong argument that is wrong is, effectively, a superpower. Not many people who are willing to argue can do that. Especially if they are capable of doing that in a persuasive, public fashion.
What's the difference? Unintentional pretence vs intentional pretence? Strong imagining vs weak imagining?
Both make an assertion. Both assign a degree of confidence.
Not confidence, acceptance.
Eg, “let’s imagine that elves are real” is distinct from “elves are real”.
There is no magic point at which hypothesis suddenly becomes fact. It's simply a matter of confidence.
“Let X” is a context bound hypothetical — we’re assuming it is true within some argument; we have perfect confidence in the hypothetical, but only within that context.
That’s distinct from an assertion, which is a statement about how the world is with some associated confidence.
To be in a position to admit that you’re wrong you’ve already got to be trying to argue that you’re right.
And HN is filled with engineers.